Friday, June 19, 2009

Posts so far for parshat Shelach

  1. Shelach sources -- revamped, with more than 100 meforshim on the parasha and haftorah.
  2. The trup on kol -- The trup, and nikkud, on the word kol of kol nasi bahem is evidence for Rashbam of the expression's meaning. He is right, but it is the words in the pasuk which determine this trup and nikkud.h
  3. Did Moshe really send nesiim as scoutsThe differing position of Rashbam on this matter, and how it works out with the harmonization with the account in sefer Devarim.h
  4. After what was Nachal Eshkol namedAfter the cluster of grapes, but what about the Biblical character Eshkol? And why does it seem to be called that before they even arrived? The Gra has an interesting suggestion, which I then analyze. See also this earlier post, about dual etymology of Nachal Eshkol.

  1. Shlach sources -- links by aliyah and perek to an online mikraos gedolos, as well as to many meforshim on the parsha and haftara.

  2. Why would Moshe send the meraglim if he knew they would sin? My own suggestion to a question posed elsewhere, based on some other Rashis.

  3. vehaAnashim asher alu imo -- explaining a masoretic note on Shelach, that there are two instances of vehaAnashim, and to remember that this one has a kadma veAzla.

  4. Why did Yehoshua send the spies? Especially given the problem which resulted from Moshe's sending of spies!

  5. Why would Moshe pray for Yehoshua and not Kalev? Rav Elyashiv has an answer, but I believe it goes against an explicit midrash or two.

  6. Was Rachav an innkeeper or a harlot? The "famous" explanation that she was an innkeeper may be the result of misreading / overreading the Targum, according to Radak. I examine all the places Targum translates zonah as pundekita and weigh it, as well as showing how Radak and Ralbag treat it.

  7. Radak is right; Rachav was a harlot. In this post, I consider one of the pundekita sources I missed, about Yiftach's mother. There, an addendum to the Targum makes it fairly explicit that pundekita means prostitute, in an explanation of the application of the name which corresponds well with Ralbag's explanation.

  8. Why does Rashi shift grasshoppers to ants? A few explanations, but I believe that the correct explanation is that he doesn't, and that by nemalim he means chagavim, since he uses that term elsewhere.

  9. Why the chirik in bin Nun? A cute answer, involving borrowing of dots...

  10. Who in the world is Nun? And I am not just saying "Yehoshua's father"...
  1. From Shadal's Vikuach -- Bamidbar Rabba for parshat Shelach notes that techeles has been hidden away, yet the gemara makes clear that the Amoraim and early Savoraim had techeiles. This can help us date Bemidbar Rabba.

  2. Was sending the spies a good thing? And what is the implication of lecha here and elsewhere? And then Rabbenu Bachya actually says it!

  3. Did Calev go by himself to Chevron? The sudden shift from plural to singular for going to Chevron, but other psukim indicate otherwise. How do different meforshim deal with this question?

  4. The Egyptians, occupied with burial -- cross-listed from Masei, a parallel midrashic theme of the enemy occupied with burying so as to not make trouble.

  5. The metaphor of tzitzis and mezuzah. In the course of this post, I mention Ramban's dismissal of Rashi's explanation of the count associated with tzitzis.
  • The Meraglim Didn't Lie. Also, why mention Hoshea and the name change.
  • From Shadal's Vikuach -- Rashbam uses trup / nikkud to determine what "kol nasi bahem" means every spy was a prince, but not that every prince was a spy.
to be continued...


Steg (dos iz nit der šteg) said...

LOL... i used to read Schlock, it was really funny. But then i started reading all these crazy Jewish blogs instead of webcomics...

Anonymous said...

My Blog
Thanks for your share
Nice to meet you

Hsinchu, Taiwan


Blog Widget by LinkWithin