Showing posts with label shmuel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shmuel. Show all posts

Sunday, February 02, 2014

Heavy is the head that wears the crown

Especially if the crown weighs a full kikar of gold!

The pasuk and Rashi from parshat Teruma:

He shall make it of a talent of pure gold, with all these implements.לט. כִּכַּר זָהָב טָהוֹר יַעֲשֶׂה אֹתָהּ אֵת כָּל הַכֵּלִים הָאֵלֶּה:
a talent pure gold: Heb. כִּכַּר.[This means] that its weight along with all its implements shall be nothing but a talent, no less and no more. The talent used for mundane matters was sixty maneh, and the one used for holy matters was double, thus one hundred twenty maneh (Bech. 5a). The maneh is the litra with which silver is weighed according to the weight used in Cologne, which is the equivalent of one hundred gold pieces [or] twenty-five selas, for the sela is equivalent to four gold pieces. [This is the equivalent of sixty-four pounds.]ככר זהב טהור: שלא יהיה משקלה עם כל כליה אלא ככר, לא פחות ולא יותר, והככר של חול ששים מנה ושל קדש היה כפול, מאה עשרים מנה, והמנה הוא ליטרא ששוקלין בה כסף למשקל קולוני"א והם מאה זהובים, עשרים וחמשה סלעים והסלע ארבעה זהובים:

Rabbenu Yona Ibn Janach writes:

That is, after relating a complex calculation of its weight, he writes:

"Like this I have seen, but it is astonishing to me, that this was not too heavy upon the kings to wear a crown of this weight upon their heads, as is stated (II Shmuel 12:30):

ל  וַיִּקַּח אֶת-עֲטֶרֶת-מַלְכָּם מֵעַל רֹאשׁוֹ וּמִשְׁקָלָהּ כִּכַּר זָהָב, וְאֶבֶן יְקָרָה, וַתְּהִי, עַל-רֹאשׁ דָּוִד; וּשְׁלַל הָעִיר הוֹצִיא, הַרְבֵּה מְאֹד.30 And he took the crown of their king from off his head; and the weight thereof was a talent of gold, and in it were precious stones; and it was set on David's head. And he brought forth the spoil of the city, exceeding much.

And therefore I don't think that this explanation is correct. Even though I have seen in a few of the commentaries that the kikar is 100 litras.

(The compiler [R' A.Z. Rabinowitz]: Yet there are some who explain מלכם not from the language of king but rather like Milcom, the deity of the Bnei Amon, see Yirmeyahu 49:1, but there [in the same pasuk in Shmuel] immediately afterwards it states, וַתְּהִי, עַל-רֹאשׁ דָּוִד, and it was on the head of David.)

(Sefer Hashorashim 229)"

End quote. I emended the translated pasuk in Shmuel above so as not to give away the Milcom deity answer, and to be consistent with Ibn Janach's translation.

For comparison, the Imperial State Crown weighs 0.9 kg, which is much less.

ImperialStateCrown.jpg

Other possibilities:
a) The phrase וַתְּהִי, עַל-רֹאשׁ דָּוִד is meant figuratively, that he took rulership.
b) It was this heavy, either of the deity or of a king, but was mounted to the throne, rather than resting on David's head.
c) divrei torah midivrei kabbalah lo yalfinan. Words as they are used in Navi are not necessarily used the same way they are used in the Torah. And so, while shekel and kikar may have a one weight unit meaning in the Torah, they might have an entirely different weight-unit meaning in sefer Shmuel.

Sunday, December 16, 2012

How many daughters did Yaakov have?

Summary: Ibn Ezra grapples with the plural mention of Yaakov's daughters and granddaughters, in light of the reference to only one of each in the ensuing genealogy. It can be plural banot to mean a single bat, or a reference to maidservants. I analyze what might be guiding Ibn Ezra in this, explain his reference to Michal bat Shaul, and have some suggestions of my own -- that there were indeed other daughters.

Post: In parshas Vayigash, the Torah makes reference to multiple daughters of Yaakov, who went down to Egypt. Bereishit 46:7:


ז  בָּנָיו וּבְנֵי בָנָיו, אִתּוֹ, בְּנֹתָיו וּבְנוֹת בָּנָיו, וְכָל-זַרְעוֹ--הֵבִיא אִתּוֹ, מִצְרָיְמָה.  {ס}7 his sons, and his sons' sons with him, his daughters, and his sons' daughters, and all his seed brought he with him into Egypt. {S}

Yet we only knew of Dinah, listed among the sons. If there were another daughter, why not mention her? And we cannot say that bnot banim harei hein kevanot, that granddaughters are reckoned as daughters, for the same pasuk explicitly references benot banav, the sons' daughters.

Ibn Ezra weighs in:

[מו, ז]
בנותיו -
היא דינה לבדה. 
ויתכן שהיו לדינה שפחות קטנות גדלו עמה ובעבור בתו קראם הכתוב בנות יעקב, בעבור שגדלו בביתו כמו בני מיכל. 
וכן: ובנות בניו. כי אחת היא.

"His daughters: this is a reference to Dinah alone. And it is possible that Dinah had young maidservants who grew up with her, and because of his daughter, the Scripture called them daughters of Yaakov, since they grew up in his home, just as the sons of Michal. And so too, 'and his sons' daughters' [in plural], where she was only one."

I have a few notes:

1) Ibn Ezra won't say here that there were other daughters. Even though he surely knows the midrash that each of Yaakov's sons was born with a twin sister, whom they married instead of marrying the prohibited local Canaanites, he will not say this, for he is trying to advance peshat.

2) Meanwhile, I do think that it is plausible that there were other unnamed daughters. The Torah only named the sons at their birth because they were to become the shivtei Kah. And Dinah's birth was only mentioned because we would soon hear of her abduction and rape at the hands of Shechem. (And Ibn Caspi even says we only hear about that so as to make sense of the curse of Shimon and Levi in Yaakov's blessing. I am not in accord with him on this point.) So Yaakov might well have had other daughters, but there was no point in mentioning them by name. See also how other sons of Yosef born alongside Ephraim and Menashe would be reckoned as part of the shevatim of Ephraim and Menashe, such that even males named in genealogies needn't account for a person's full output.

3) Another difficulty that is likely guiding Ibn Ezra is how to count up the numbered and named people who descended to Egypt. Only Dinah bat Yaakov and Serach bat Asher are explicitly named and are part of the count in the enumeration which follows in the next pesukim. How could other daughters have been born if they were not named and counted?

This is what Ibn Ezra means by  ובנות בניו. כי אחת היא. The one son's daughter he refers to is Serach bat Asher. Therefore, it must be that the plural banot means bat. We can turn to the parallel of Dan's one son, Chushim:


כג  וּבְנֵי-דָן, חֻשִׁים.23 And the sons of Dan: Hushim.


where bnei is used. This is true and convincing enough.

Meanwhile, at least for sons' daughters, Rashi has no problem, for he is willing to say that Yocheved, daughter of Levi, was born between the gates, entering into Egypt.

4) I am reluctant to say, though, that there were so few girls in the entire company of seventy souls from Yaakov's loins who went down to Egypt. See what I posted here. I would rather say that these are the ones who were explicitly listed, for reasons we know or don't know. Perhaps Serach was important for some extrabiblical or genealogical reason we don't know about, and the Torah here is citing those genealogical sources to provide the accounting.

5) In association with that, the idea that she was the one who played the harp to gently break the news to Yaakov that Yosef was still alive -- that is a midrash. I don't know that this would be the historical reason for what I propose above, for her inclusion in the list while other girls were not.

6) To explain Ibn Ezra's reference to the sons of Michal bat Shaul, we see in II Shmuel 21:8:
ח  וַיִּקַּח הַמֶּלֶךְ אֶת-שְׁנֵי בְּנֵי רִצְפָּה בַת-אַיָּה, אֲשֶׁר יָלְדָה לְשָׁאוּל, אֶת-אַרְמֹנִי, וְאֶת-מְפִבֹשֶׁת; וְאֶת-חֲמֵשֶׁת, בְּנֵי מִיכַל בַּת-שָׁאוּל, אֲשֶׁר יָלְדָה לְעַדְרִיאֵל בֶּן-בַּרְזִלַּי, הַמְּחֹלָתִי.8 But the king took the two sons of Rizpah the daughter of Aiah, whom she bore unto Saul, Armoni and Mephibosheth; and the five sons of Michal the daughter of Saul, whom she bore to Adriel the son of Barzillai the Meholathite;
ט  וַיִּתְּנֵם בְּיַד הַגִּבְעֹנִים, וַיֹּקִיעֻם בָּהָר לִפְנֵי ה, וַיִּפְּלוּ שבעתים (שְׁבַעְתָּם), יָחַד; והם (וְהֵמָּה) הֻמְתוּ בִּימֵי קָצִיר, בָּרִאשֹׁנִים, תחלת (בִּתְחִלַּת), קְצִיר שְׂעֹרִים.9 and he delivered them into the hands of the Gibeonites, and they hanged them in the mountain before the LORD, and they fell all seven together; and they were put to death in the days of harvest, in the first days, at the beginning of barley harvest.


that Michal bat Shaul had five sons. King David, who married Michal, is delivering her sons whom she bore to Adriel the son or Barzilah, up for death.

Yet, in II Shmuel 6:23, we read:
כ  וַיָּשָׁב דָּוִד, לְבָרֵךְ אֶת-בֵּיתוֹ;  {ס}  וַתֵּצֵא מִיכַל בַּת-שָׁאוּל, לִקְרַאת דָּוִד, וַתֹּאמֶר מַה-נִּכְבַּד הַיּוֹם מֶלֶךְ יִשְׂרָאֵל אֲשֶׁר נִגְלָה הַיּוֹם לְעֵינֵי אַמְהוֹת עֲבָדָיו, כְּהִגָּלוֹת נִגְלוֹת אַחַד הָרֵקִים.20 Then David returned to bless his household. {S} And Michal the daughter of Saul came out to meet David, and said: 'How did the king of Israel get him honour to-day, who uncovered himself to-day in the eyes of the handmaids of his servants, as one of the vain fellows shamelessly uncovereth himself!'
כא  וַיֹּאמֶר דָּוִד, אֶל-מִיכַל, לִפְנֵי ה אֲשֶׁר בָּחַר-בִּי מֵאָבִיךְ וּמִכָּל-בֵּיתוֹ, לְצַוֹּת אֹתִי נָגִיד עַל-עַם ה עַל-יִשְׂרָאֵל; וְשִׂחַקְתִּי, לִפְנֵי ה.21 And David said unto Michal: 'Before the LORD, who chose me above thy father, and above all his house, to appoint me prince over the people of the LORD, over Israel, before the LORD will I make merry.
כב  וּנְקַלֹּתִי עוֹד מִזֹּאת, וְהָיִיתִי שָׁפָל בְּעֵינָי; וְעִם-הָאֲמָהוֹת אֲשֶׁר אָמַרְתְּ, עִמָּם אִכָּבֵדָה.22 And I will be yet more vile than thus, and will be base in mine own sight; and with the handmaids whom thou hast spoken of, with them will I get me honour.'
כג  וּלְמִיכַל, בַּת-שָׁאוּל, לֹא-הָיָה לָהּ, יָלֶד--עַד, יוֹם מוֹתָהּ.  {פ}23 And Michal the daughter of Saul had no child unto the day of her death. {P}


Thus, she died childless, so how could she have had five children?

Furthermore, in David's absence, though Shaul had earlier promised her to David, King Shaul had given Michal to marry Palti ben Laish, not to Adriel ben Barzilai. I Shmuel 25:


מד  וְשָׁאוּל, נָתַן אֶת-מִיכַל בִּתּוֹ--אֵשֶׁת דָּוִד:  לְפַלְטִי בֶן-לַיִשׁ, אֲשֶׁר מִגַּלִּים.44 Now Saul had given Michal his daughter, David's wife, to Palti the son of Laish, who was of Gallim.


And the one who married Adriel ben Barzilai was actually a different daughter of Shaul promised to David, Michal's sister Merav. I Shmuel 18:19:
יז  וַיֹּאמֶר שָׁאוּל אֶל-דָּוִד, הִנֵּה בִתִּי הַגְּדוֹלָה מֵרַב אֹתָהּ אֶתֶּן-לְךָ לְאִשָּׁה--אַךְ הֱיֵה-לִי לְבֶן-חַיִל, וְהִלָּחֵם מִלְחֲמוֹת ה; וְשָׁאוּל אָמַר, אַל-תְּהִי יָדִי בּוֹ, וּתְהִי-בוֹ, יַד-פְּלִשְׁתִּים.  {ס}17 And Saul said to David: 'Behold my elder daughter Merab, her will I give thee to wife; only be thou valiant for me, and fight the LORD'S battles.' For Saul said: 'Let not my hand be upon him, but let the hand of the Philistines be upon him.' {S}
יח  וַיֹּאמֶר דָּוִד אֶל-שָׁאוּל, מִי אָנֹכִי וּמִי חַיַּי, מִשְׁפַּחַת אָבִי, בְּיִשְׂרָאֵל--כִּי-אֶהְיֶה חָתָן, לַמֶּלֶךְ.18 And David said unto Saul: 'Who am I, and what is my life, or my father's family in Israel, that I should be son-in-law to the king?'
יט  וַיְהִי, בְּעֵת תֵּת אֶת-מֵרַב בַּת-שָׁאוּל--לְדָוִד; וְהִיא נִתְּנָה לְעַדְרִיאֵל הַמְּחֹלָתִי, לְאִשָּׁה.19 But it came to pass at the time when Merab Saul's daughter should have been given to David, that she was given unto Adriel the Meholathite to wife.
כ  וַתֶּאֱהַב מִיכַל בַּת-שָׁאוּל, אֶת-דָּוִד; וַיַּגִּדוּ לְשָׁאוּל, וַיִּשַׁר הַדָּבָר בְּעֵינָיו.20 And Michal Saul's daughter loved David; and they told Saul, and the thing pleased him.


There are two ways to resolve this contradiction.

The first is that there is a taus sofer in our Sefer Shmuel. This is not necessarily kefirah, to the same degree as it would be to assert this for the Torah. And it is plausible, given the many such discrepencies in sefer Shmuel (and associated Divrei HaYamim) that could be readily explained in like manner.

The second is what Ibn Ezra is suggesting here, that where the pasuk states:

וְאֶת-חֲמֵשֶׁת, בְּנֵי מִיכַל בַּת-שָׁאוּל, אֲשֶׁר יָלְדָה לְעַדְרִיאֵל בֶּן-בַּרְזִלַּי, הַמְּחֹלָתִי.

they are called her sons, even though they were actually Merav's sons, because she raised them up. And presumably he would dismiss אֲשֶׁר יָלְדָה which typically means birthed, as being raised. And this would then be precedence for other girls raised in Yaakov's house to be called his daughters. At the end of the day, I don't find this argument convincing.

Update: As Shmuel (the commenter, not the Navi or Sefer) points out in the comment section:
The explanation re Michal is not only Ibn Ezra's; it comes from Sanhedrin 19b and is quoted by Rashi too.
We can see this gemara in Sanhedrin here:
Now as to R. Joshua b. Korha,26  surely it is written, And the five sons of Michal the daughter of Saul whom she bore to Adriel. — R. Joshua [b. Korha] answers thee: Was it then Michal who bore them? Surely it was rather Merab who bore them! But Merab bore and Michal brought them up; therefore they were called by her name. This teaches thee that whoever brings up an orphan in his home, Scripture ascribes it to him as though he had begotten him.
Despite it appearing in a midrash in the gemara, Ibn Ezra surely regards it as peshat. If one is not going to ascribe it to scribal error, it is difficult to make sense of the pesukim otherwise. After all, Michal was explicitly unmarried at the time she married David, and was the replacement for her sister who indeed married Adriel.

Despite it appearing in a gemara, at the end of the day, I still don't find this argument convincing.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

The shaking, or shaken, earth

Summary: Considering a krei and ketiv in the haftara, according to Meshech Chochma.

Post: In the haftara for Haazinu, in II Shmuel 22, we read:

ז  בַּצַּר-לִי אֶקְרָא ה, וְאֶל-אֱלֹהַי אֶקְרָא;  {ס}  וַיִּשְׁמַע מֵהֵיכָלוֹ קוֹלִי, וְשַׁוְעָתִי בְּאָזְנָיו.  {ר}7 In my distress I called upon the LORD, yea, I called unto my God; and out of His temple He heard my voice, and my cry did enter into His ears.
ח  ותגעש (וַיִּתְגָּעַשׁ) וַתִּרְעַשׁ הָאָרֶץ,  {ס}  מוֹסְדוֹת הַשָּׁמַיִם יִרְגָּזוּ; וַיִּתְגָּעֲשׁוּ, כִּי-חָרָה לוֹ.  {ר}8 Then the earth did shake and quake, the foundations of heaven did tremble; they were shaken, because He was wroth.


Note the krei and ketiv. This is all part of a shir which David HaMelech sang, as it states in pasuk 1. There is a parallel song in Tehillim 18:8:


ז  בַּצַּר-לִי, אֶקְרָא יְהוָה--    וְאֶל-אֱלֹהַי אֲשַׁוֵּעַ:
יִשְׁמַע מֵהֵיכָלוֹ קוֹלִי;    וְשַׁוְעָתִי, לְפָנָיו תָּבוֹא בְאָזְנָיו.
7 In my distress I called upon the LORD, and cried unto my God;{N}
out of His temple He heard my voice, and my cry came before Him unto His ears.
ח  וַתִּגְעַשׁ וַתִּרְעַשׁ, הָאָרֶץ--    וּמוֹסְדֵי הָרִים יִרְגָּזוּ;
וַיִּתְגָּעֲשׁוּ,    כִּי-חָרָה לוֹ.
8 Then the earth did shake and quake, the foundations also of the mountains did tremble; {N}
they were shaken, because He was wroth.

And there, there is no krei and ketiv alternation, but the krei is in line with the ketiv. The difference, it seems to me, is that one, וַתִּגְעַשׁ, is the third person feminine past, while the other, וַיִּתְגָּעַשׁ, is the third person masculine reflexive (or passive) past. The former matches the pattern of the immediately following word, וַתִּרְעַשׁ, while the latter matches the later occurrence of וַיִּתְגָּעֲשׁוּ in the pasuk, though the subject later is the masculine plural מוֹסְדֵי הָרִים. Given the possibility of corruption from the later word וַיִּתְגָּעֲשׁוּ, given that even in Shmuel it only appears as an alternative krei, and given that in Tehillim we only have one, I would side with וַתִּגְעַשׁ as the correct one. This is if we consider krei and ketiv as the competing possibilities, with only one being correct.

In terms of meaning, I don't really see any major difference between the alternatives. Either way, the earth is literally or metaphorically shaking.

Meshech Chochma discusses this alternation. After citing the pasuk, he writes:


"And the ketiv according to the peshat is וַתִּגְעַשׁ, and so too in Tehillim. And this is strange, for the krei is against the peshat. And it appears that it is going upon the heichal, that the heichal is shaken, and from this, the earth quakes, just as they darshen in Yoma 54b:

וחכמים אומרים מציון נברא שנאמר (תהלים נ, א) מזמור לאסף אל אלהים ה' ואומר מציון מכלל יופי ממנו מוכלל יפיו של עולם
that the earth was created from Tziyon, for it is stated {in Tehillim}, מציון מכלל יופי. And this is the center, and from there it is shaken, and from there the earth shakes, and it is pashut."

This is an interesting way of parsing the pesukim, and one which I would not have thought of. And I think it would account for the masculine of וַיִּתְגָּעַשׁ (though ארץ might be able to support either).

Radak does not see any substantive difference between the krei and the ketiv:
[כב, ח]
ותגעש -
כתיב כמו בתהלים וקרי ויתגעש והענין אחד, וקריאת המלה מלרע וכל הענין הזה עד ישלח ממרום רמז להשחית ולכלות אויבי ישראל, כי להם הוא רעש הארץ והשמים וחשך וערפל וגחלים ואש וחצים וברק, הכל דרך משל. 
He says vehainyan echad.

The Targum renders both וַתִּגְעַשׁ  and וַתִּרְעַשׁ as the itpael. Rashi, in saying that the head of the pasuk is mechubar to its end, might be mapping וַיִּתְגָּעַשׁ of the krei to the end.

Tuesday, June 08, 2010

Why it should not be lo *chamud* echad meihem nasasi

Summary: Continuing a point from years past, I point out that the Samaritans also have chamud as opposed to chamor. But then explain why it is almost certainly incorrect.

Post: I spotted the following in Vetus Testamentum the other day. The text to the left is our Masoretic text, while the text to the right is the Samaritan text:

Whereas in our text Moshe states that he did not take a single donkey from them, the Samaritans have him say that he did not take a single desirous thing from them. It is easy for a copyist to make this error, as a resh and a daled look quite similar to one another.

As I noted in the past, the Septuagint is based on the same mistake. Thus:
15 καὶ ἐβαρυθύμησε Μωυσῆς σφόδρα καὶ εἶπε πρὸς Κύριον· μὴ πρόσχῃς εἰς τὴν θυσίαν αὐτῶν· οὐκ ἐπιθύμημα οὐδενὸς αὐτῶν εἴληφα, οὐδὲ ἐκάκωσα οὐδένα αὐτῶν.
15 And Moses was exceeding indignant, and said to the Lord, Do thou take no heed to their sacrifice: I have not taken away the desire of any one of them, neither have I hurt any one of them.

But, as I have noted in the past as well, besides semantic reasons to prefer the Masoretic text, the pasuk in Sefer Shmuel, I 12:3 more or less clinches it.


ג  הִנְנִי עֲנוּ בִי נֶגֶד ה' וְנֶגֶד מְשִׁיחוֹ, אֶת-שׁוֹר מִי לָקַחְתִּי וַחֲמוֹר מִי לָקַחְתִּי וְאֶת-מִי עָשַׁקְתִּי אֶת-מִי רַצּוֹתִי, וּמִיַּד-מִי לָקַחְתִּי כֹפֶר, וְאַעְלִים עֵינַי בּוֹ; וְאָשִׁיב, לָכֶם.3 Here I am; witness against me before the LORD, and before His anointed: whose ox have I taken? or whose ass have I taken? or whom have I defrauded? or whom have I oppressed? or of whose hand have I taken a ransom to blind mine eyes therewith? and I will restore it you.'


Note how shor is placed parallel to chamor in parallel phrases (mi lakachti). And also, the Septuagint does not have chamud there, but chamor.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Chizkuni on Rashi, and "You are not *able* to eat"

In parshat Re'ei, a commandment that we must eat certain foods only in Yerushalayim. Devarim 12:17:

יז לֹא-תוּכַל לֶאֱכֹל בִּשְׁעָרֶיךָ, מַעְשַׂר דְּגָנְךָ וְתִירֹשְׁךָ וְיִצְהָרֶךָ, וּבְכֹרֹת בְּקָרְךָ, וְצֹאנֶךָ; וְכָל-נְדָרֶיךָ אֲשֶׁר תִּדֹּר, וְנִדְבֹתֶיךָ וּתְרוּמַת יָדֶךָ.17 Thou mayest not eat within thy gates the tithe of thy corn, or of thy wine, or of thine oil, or the firstlings of thy herd or of thy flock, nor any of thy vows which thou vowest, nor thy freewill-offerings, nor the offering of thy hand;
Upon this, Rashi writes:

You may not eat within your cities the tithe of your grain]:Scripture comes to attach a negative commandment to this matter [i.e., eating the firstborn, tithes, etc., outside the walls of Jerusalem, in addition to the positive command (stated in verse 6)].

You may not [eat]: [Heb. לֹא תוּכַל lit., “you cannot eat.”] Rabbi Joshua the son of Korchah said: You are able, but you are not permitted [to do so]. Similar to this, in the verse “As to the Jebusites, the inhabitants of Jerusalem, the children of Judah could not drive them out” (Josh. 15:63), they were [physically] able to do so but they were not so permitted, since Abraham had made a [non-aggression] treaty with them when he bought the cave of Machpelah from them. [In fact,] they were not Jebusites [of the Jebusite nation] but Hittites. They were, however, called Jebusites after the city, named Jebus. So it is explained in Pirkei d’Rabbi Eliezer (chapter 36). And this is what is stated [when David was about to drive out the Jebusites. They said to him], “Unless you take away the blind and the lame [you shall not come in here]” (II Sam. 5:6), [referring to] the images [that stood at the gates] upon which the oath [that Abraham had taken regarding the Jebusites] was written.

לא תוכל: בא הכתוב ליתן לא תעשה על הדבר.

רבי יהושע בן קרחה אומר יכול אתה, אבל אינך רשאי, כיוצא בו (יהושע טו, סג) ואת היבוסי יושבי ירושלים לא יכלו בני יהודה להורישם, יכולים היו, אלא שאינן רשאין, לפי שכרת להם אברהם ברית כשלקח מהם מערת המכפלה. ולא יבוסים היו אלא חתיים היו, אלא על שם העיר ששמה יבוס [נקראים יבוסים]. כך מפורש בפרקי דרבי אליעזר. והוא שנאמר (שמואל ב' ה, ו) כי אם הסירך העורים והפסחים, צלמים שכתבו עליהם את השבועה:



Chizkuni points out a contradiction in Rashi. If we look in II Shmuel 5:6, Rashi says that the Yevusites were descendants of Avimelech, rather than the descendants of the Chitti with whom he made a treaty upon the purchase of the mearat hamachpela. Chizkuni explains that this is not in accordance with Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha.









To expand on this just a bit, in sefer Yehoshua, we are told that they were not able to conquer the Yevusi. And later on, in II Melachim 5:6, King David conquers the Yevusi:
ו וַיֵּלֶךְ הַמֶּלֶךְ וַאֲנָשָׁיו יְרוּשָׁלִַם, אֶל-הַיְבֻסִי יוֹשֵׁב הָאָרֶץ; וַיֹּאמֶר לְדָוִד לֵאמֹר, לֹא-תָבוֹא הֵנָּה, כִּי אִם-הֱסִירְךָ הַעִוְרִים וְהַפִּסְחִים לֵאמֹר, לֹא-יָבוֹא דָוִד הֵנָּה.6 And the king and his men went to Jerusalem against the Jebusites, the inhabitants of the land, who spoke unto David, saying: 'Except thou take away the blind and the lame, thou shalt not come in hither'; thinking: 'David cannot come in hither.'
ז וַיִּלְכֹּד דָּוִד, אֵת מְצֻדַת צִיּוֹן--הִיא, עִיר דָּוִד.7 Nevertheless David took the stronghold of Zion; the same is the city of David.
ח וַיֹּאמֶר דָּוִד בַּיּוֹם הַהוּא, כָּל-מַכֵּה יְבֻסִי וְיִגַּע בַּצִּנּוֹר, וְאֶת-הַפִּסְחִים וְאֶת-הַעִוְרִים, שנאו (שְׂנוּאֵי) נֶפֶשׁ דָּוִד; עַל-כֵּן, יֹאמְרוּ, עִוֵּר וּפִסֵּחַ, לֹא יָבוֹא אֶל-הַבָּיִת.8 And David said on that day: 'Whosoever smiteth the Jebusites, and getteth up to the gutter, and [taketh away] the lame and the blind, that are hated of David's soul--.' Wherefore they say: 'There are the blind and the lame; he cannot come into the house.'

On this, Rashi explains that:
to the Jebusites: Mezudath Zion is called Jebus. Now they (the inhabitants of the area) were of the seed of Abimelech, and they were in possession of two statues, one blind and the other lame, symbolizing Isaac (who was blind in his latter years. See Gen. 22:1) and Jacob (who turned lame as a result of his bout with the angel. See Gen. 32:26), and in their mouths was the oath that Abraham had sworn to Abimelech (Gen. 22:23). For this reason they (the Israelites who had conquered the land) did not drive them out, for when they took Jerusalem they failed to take the stronghold, as it is stated: “And the Jebusites, the inhabitants of Jerusalem, the people of Judah were unable, etc.” (Josh. 15:63) - it was learned: R. Joshua b. Levi said: They were indeed able but were not permitted.
and he spoke to David: the one who spoke
the blind and the lame: these were their idols.

This is thus a slightly different origin. And Chizkuni asserts that what Rashi says in sefer Shmuel, that they were descendants of Avimelech, rather than saying that it was the Chiti, is not like Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha.

I am not convinced that this is so. I don't see any reference to Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha in Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer. And on the relevant pasuk in sefer Yehoshua, what appears to be a quote by Rashi from Sifrei seems to put both the inability and the descending from Avimelech in the mouth of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha:
the children of Judah could not drive them out: We learned in Sifrei : Rabbi Joshua the son of Korha says: They really could, but they were not permitted, because of the oath which Abraham had sworn to Abimelech. Now these Jebusites were not of the Jebusite nation, but the Tower of David which was in Jerusalem, was called Jebus, and the inhabitants of that section were of the Philistines. And when the children of Judah conquered Jerusalem, they did not drive out the inhabitants of that section.
So Rashi seems to see this as working well together with Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha's position, whether Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha actually said it or not. I would note that the Sifrei does not actually mention why they were unable, at least in parshat Re'eh:

ל א תוכל לאכול בשעריך • ר׳ יהושע בן קרחת אומר יכול (אני) אבל איני רשאי •
כיוצא בו אתה אומר (יהושע טו) ואת היבוסי יושבי ירושלים לא יכלו להורישם
יכולים היו אבל אינן רשאים :

So it can work either way.

Regardless, if this oath was in place in the time of Yehoshua such that they were unable to conquer, why was David able to conquer? Was he not violating the oath here? Rashi does not give an answer.

But Chizkuni offers it. He notes that there was a restriction on the oath. In Bereishit 21:23:
כג וְעַתָּה, הִשָּׁבְעָה לִּי בֵאלֹהִים הֵנָּה, אִם-תִּשְׁקֹר לִי, וּלְנִינִי וּלְנֶכְדִּי; כַּחֶסֶד אֲשֶׁר-עָשִׂיתִי עִמְּךָ, תַּעֲשֶׂה עִמָּדִי, וְעִם-הָאָרֶץ, אֲשֶׁר-גַּרְתָּה בָּהּ.23 Now therefore swear unto me here by God that thou wilt not deal falsely with me, nor with my son, nor with my son's son; but according to the kindness that I have done unto thee, thou shalt do unto me, and to the land wherein thou hast sojourned.'
כד וַיֹּאמֶר, אַבְרָהָם, אָנֹכִי, אִשָּׁבֵעַ.24 And Abraham said: 'I will swear.'

{As as aside, I wonder if הִשָּׁבְעָה לִּי בֵאלֹהִים הֵנָּה in Bereishit was the basis for the idea of the oath inscribed on idols, of course paired with the lame and the blind local to sefer Shmuel.}

Chizkuni notes that the oath was to his son and his son's son. But by the time of David, Avimelech's grandchildren were no longer around. If so, why would the Yevusi think they were protected by the lame and the blind, that is the oath? The answer Chizkuni offers is that they were mistaken in their assumption.

I am not certain I agree with this assumption, for those generations should have passed already by the time of Yehoshua. This was made at the end of Avraham's life, and yet the oath was in place. Perhaps one can say that such an oath was conditional, and some condition was violated? Perhaps this is why David wanted to get rid of the statues of the blind and the lame?

Indeed, looking in sefer Shmuel, the assumption seems to be that so long as the statues are present (with the oaths), David is unable. And thus the intent to eliminate them. Citing Rashi there:
Whoever smites the Jebusites and reaches the tower: Whosoever kills the Jebusites and is first to capture the city.
and the lame: and he also smites the lame and the blind and those despised by the soul, etc.
wherefore they say: On (account of) that which they say,
The blind and the lame (etc.: So long as the blind and the lame be here… he shall not, etc.

You can read the Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer online here at HebrewBooks.org, starting at the last line of this page (199) and continuing on to the next pages. Indeed, looking at Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer, it is clear that David was also bound by this oath so long as those idols bearing Avraham's oath was there, and that was why he commanded to get rid of those idols.

So I will have to argue with Chizkuni on that count as well.

Of course, on a peshat level, the meaning of the "were not able" in sefer Yehoshua is that they were physically not able. And the lame and the blind in sefer Shmuel, I would guess, are indeed idols, and the Yevusi thought incorrectly that their deities would protect them. And David wished to uproot and destroy idolatry, and that is why he wanted them eliminated.

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Who in the world is Bedan?

In the haftarah of parshat Korach, Shmuel makes mention of a shofet named Bedan.

יא וַיִּשְׁלַח יְהוָה אֶת-יְרֻבַּעַל וְאֶת-בְּדָן, וְאֶת-יִפְתָּח וְאֶת-שְׁמוּאֵל; וַיַּצֵּל אֶתְכֶם מִיַּד אֹיְבֵיכֶם, מִסָּבִיב, וַתֵּשְׁבוּ, בֶּטַח.11 And the LORD sent Jerubbaal, and Bedan, and Jephthah, and Samuel, and delivered you out of the hand of your enemies on every side, and ye dwelt in safety.

But who in the world is this fellow? We see no mention of him in sefer Shofetim, which given its chronological pattern of shofet after shofet after shofet, would not seem to have any space for a gap, and an additional judge.

All the meforshim -- Targum, Rashi, Mahari Kara, Radak, Metzudat David, Ralbag, Malbim -- identify Bedan as Shimshon. They all get it from the gemara (Rosh Hashanah 25a - b), which has:
ואומר (שמואל א יב) ויאמר שמואל אל העם ה' אשר עשה את משה ואת אהרן ואומר (שמואל א יב) וישלח ה' את ירובעל ואת בדן ואת יפתח ואת שמואל ירובעל זה גדעון ולמה נקרא שמו ירובעל שעשה מריבה עם הבעל בדן זה שמשון ולמה נקרא שמו בדן דאתי מדן יפתח כמשמעו
דף כה, ב גמרא ואומר (תהילים צט) משה ואהרן בכהניו ושמואל בקוראי שמו שקל הכתוב שלשה קלי עולם כשלשה חמורי עולם לומר לך ירובעל בדורו כמשה בדורו בדן בדורו כאהרן בדורו יפתח בדורו כשמואל בדורו ללמדך שאפילו קל שבקלין ונתמנה פרנס על הצבור הרי הוא כאביר שבאבירים

The purported connection is bedan as ba from dan, and Shimshon was the shofet from the tribe of Dan. But the influence of this explanation is almost surely the closed-canon approach. That is, if you have a Biblical figure otherwise unidentified as famous, and all of a sudden brought to brief prominence, conflate them with another famous Biblical figure. Thus, the eved Avraham who went to pick up Rivka was surely Eliezer, Shifra and Puah were Yocheved and Miriam, and the two anonymous spies Yehoshua sent in last week's haftarah were Calev and Pinchas. So too, Bedan is the famous Shimshon. Radak notes an irregularity, that the chronologically later Shimshon is then placed after Yiftach in the pasuk, but he answers that the order is based on their greatness. (I would also add that Yerubaal is one of two names for the same individual, namely Gideon, so saying that Shimshon had two names, though not mentioned elsewhere explicitly in the text, is slightly plausible.)

There is another possibility. The LXX (Septuagint, an early Greek translation), the Syriac translation, and the Arabic translation all have Barak instead of Bedan. (I would point out a slight irregularity that we might have expected Devorah rather than her lackey.) We can treat the evidence from these sources in one of two ways. We could note that each of these is a translation of a Hebrew original, and even in our own Targum, Bedan was "translated" to another shofet, namely Shimshon. We cannot know that some other tradition (perhaps based on a closed-canon approach) did not develop that Bedan was Barak, and that this is what these translations are doing. If it is translation rather than mere transcription, then these sources are much less relevant.

On the other hand, we could presume that these are transcriptions of the Hebrew, rather than translations. They would then reflect a variant girsa. Even so, the variant girsa could reflect an error, but still, we would be faced with variant versions of the text. We would think it likely that this reflects a variant girsa because both בדן and ברק begin with a bet; there is orthographic similarity between the daled and the resh; and similarly between the long nun sofit and the kuf. If so, scribal error could produce either variant from the other.

Even if we are dealing with a scribal error creating a variant, my assumption is that our Masoretic text is the correct one. This is not just because I like defending our tradition. Rather, there is a principle of lectio difficilior, the rule of the difficult word being more likely to be original. Of course, some corruptions will make the text insensible, but the idea behind it is as follows: Which is more likely, to change a text from an otherwise unknown shofet into a famous one, or vice versa? Bedan would seem like an error, so a scribe would be less likely to write it; but in a confusing source text, a scribe is quite likely to arrive at Barak, believe it to make sense, and maintain it.

They key behind lectio difficilior, when I use it at least, is that there is an obvious and immediately apparent difficulty with one of the choices over the other, but on closer scrutiny and consideration, one can make a compelling case for the other choice.

And here is my compelling case. It is not true that we do not know Bedan from elsewhere. The name is found in I Divrei Hayamim 7:
טו וּמָכִיר לָקַח אִשָּׁה, לְחֻפִּים וּלְשֻׁפִּים, וְשֵׁם אֲחֹתוֹ מַעֲכָה, וְשֵׁם הַשֵּׁנִי צְלָפְחָד; וַתִּהְיֶנָה לִצְלָפְחָד, בָּנוֹת.15 and Machir took a wife of Huppim and Shuppim, whose sister's name was Maacah--and the name of the second was Zelophehad; and Zelophehad had daughters.
טז וַתֵּלֶד מַעֲכָה אֵשֶׁת-מָכִיר, בֵּן, וַתִּקְרָא שְׁמוֹ פֶּרֶשׁ, וְשֵׁם אָחִיו שָׁרֶשׁ; וּבָנָיו, אוּלָם וָרָקֶם.16 And Maacah the wife of Machir bore a son, and she called his name Peresh; and the name of his brother was Sheresh; and his sons were Ulam and Rekem.
יז וּבְנֵי אוּלָם, בְּדָן; אֵלֶּה בְּנֵי גִלְעָד, בֶּן-מָכִיר בֶּן-מְנַשֶּׁה.17 And the sons of Ulam: Bedan. These were the sons of Gilead the son of Machir, the son of Manasseh.
Now the next shofet in the list, Yiftach, was the son of a Gilead, and a descendant of the famous Gilead, and lived in Gilead in Menasheh's portion. And the shofet previous to him was Yair, of Gilead, and perhaps his thirty sons as well.

ג וַיָּקָם אַחֲרָיו, יָאִיר הַגִּלְעָדִי; וַיִּשְׁפֹּט, אֶת-יִשְׂרָאֵל, עֶשְׂרִים וּשְׁתַּיִם, שָׁנָה.3 And after him arose Jair, the Gileadite; and he judged Israel twenty and two years.
ד וַיְהִי-לוֹ שְׁלֹשִׁים בָּנִים, רֹכְבִים עַל-שְׁלֹשִׁים עֲיָרִים, וּשְׁלֹשִׁים עֲיָרִים, לָהֶם; לָהֶם יִקְרְאוּ חַוֹּת יָאִיר, עַד הַיּוֹם הַזֶּה, אֲשֶׁר, בְּאֶרֶץ הַגִּלְעָד.4 And he had thirty sons that rode on thirty ass colts, and they had thirty cities, which are called Havvoth-jair unto this day, which are in the land of Gilead.
ה וַיָּמָת יָאִיר, וַיִּקָּבֵר בְּקָמוֹן. {פ}5 And Jair died, and was buried in Kamon.
Without bothering to work out the chronology of Divrei Hayamim, perhaps there was another shofet from Gilead wedged in there, either the one in Divrei Hayamim or someone bearing that name, since we see that names sometimes recur within families (such as Gilead).

If so, we might adopt a quasi-open canon approach. It is only- quasi since we do find this person (or this name) elsewhere in Tanach. But we can assume that it is not someone who was named explicitly in sefer Shofetim as a judge.

To Shmuel's audience, who lived at that time, Bedan would indeed be famous. But he was left on the cutting room floor of sefer Shofetim, so later generations did not know what to do with this reference. If so, Bedan gets sudden significance, hidden until now. It has a plausibility which is not immediately apparent. And thus I would favor it in a contest against Barak.

I will leave off with a nice parallel. In sefer Yechezkel, we have the following:
יג בֶּן-אָדָם, אֶרֶץ כִּי תֶחֱטָא-לִי לִמְעָל-מַעַל, וְנָטִיתִי יָדִי עָלֶיהָ, וְשָׁבַרְתִּי לָהּ מַטֵּה-לָחֶם; וְהִשְׁלַחְתִּי-בָהּ רָעָב, וְהִכְרַתִּי מִמֶּנָּה אָדָם וּבְהֵמָה.13 'Son of man, when a land sinneth against Me by trespassing grievously, and I stretch out My hand upon it, and break the staff of the bread thereof, and send famine upon it, and cut off from it man and beast;
יד וְהָיוּ שְׁלֹשֶׁת הָאֲנָשִׁים הָאֵלֶּה, בְּתוֹכָהּ--נֹחַ, דנאל (דָּנִיֵּאל) וְאִיּוֹב: הֵמָּה בְצִדְקָתָם יְנַצְּלוּ נַפְשָׁם, נְאֻם אֲדֹנָי יְהוִה.14 though these three men, Noah, Daniel, and Job, were in it, they should deliver but their own souls by their righteousness, saith the Lord GOD.
Note the krei and ketiv for Daniel, as Danel. It turns out that Danel was a famous figure in the Ancient Near East as a wise and righteous king. (See here.) So we have in this pasuk three famous gentile figures, renowned for their righteousness. It is only a later reader who has no clue who Danel is, and substitutes Daniel in its place. The open-canon approach in this case is almost certainly correct.

Sunday, April 12, 2009

Shmuel sources

This will be useful for me. Don't know if so much for you. Here is a link by perek to Shmuel, as well as collections of meforshim on Shmuel. My intent is to add to it slowly as I find more sources.

I Shmuel
perek 1 ; perek 2 ; perek 3 ; perek 4 ; perek 5
perek 6 ; perek 7 ; perek 8 ; perek 9 ; perek 10
perek 11 ; perek 12 ; perek 13 ; perek 14 ; perek 15
perek 16 ; perek 17 ; perek 18 ; perek 19 ; perek 20
perek 21 ; perek 22 ; perek 23 ; perek 24 ; perek 25
perek 26 ; perek 27 ; perek 28 ; perek 29 ; perek 30
perek 31

II Shmuel
perek 1 ; perek 2 ; perek 3 ; perek 4 ; perek 5
perek 6 ; perek 7 ; perek 8 ; perek 9 ; perek 10
perek 11 ; perek 12 ; perek 13 ; perek 14 ; perek 15
perek 16 ; perek 17 ; perek 18 ; perek 19 ; perek 20
perek 21 ; perek 22 ; perek 23 ; perek 24

in same sefer,
seder olam raba, with commentary of gra

meforshim on Shmuel
minchat shai on shmuel
rashi in English
Daat, with Yalkit Shimoni
midrash shmuel rabata
http://aleph500.huji.ac.il/nnl/dig/books/bk001987558.html
http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=33214&pgnum=1
JNUL:
Abarbanel (pg 76)
Kli Yakar (pg 138, right)

Aharon ben Yosef the Karaite (pg 21)

Monday, December 15, 2008

Parallels Between The Incident of Tamar and Amnon, And Parshat Vayeshev

It seems clear that this is either a case of history repeating itself (maaseh avot siman la-banim) or deliberate echoing of themes. Where the author of Shmuel, who recorded the incident of Amnon and Tamar, was clearly was familiar with parshat Vayeshev, in which the selling of Yosef is juxtaposed with the incident of Yehuda and Tamar.

Because it is not just that the woman in play was named Tamar. Look at the following text:
יח וְעָלֶיהָ כְּתֹנֶת פַּסִּים, כִּי כֵן תִּלְבַּשְׁןָ בְנוֹת-הַמֶּלֶךְ הַבְּתוּלֹת מְעִילִים; וַיֹּצֵא אוֹתָהּ מְשָׁרְתוֹ הַחוּץ, וְנָעַל הַדֶּלֶת אַחֲרֶיהָ. 18 Now she had a garment of many colours upon her; for with such robes were the king's daughters that were virgins apparelled.--And his servant brought her out, and bolted the door after her.
יט וַתִּקַּח תָּמָר אֵפֶר עַל-רֹאשָׁהּ, וּכְתֹנֶת הַפַּסִּים אֲשֶׁר עָלֶיהָ קָרָעָה; וַתָּשֶׂם יָדָהּ עַל-רֹאשָׁהּ, וַתֵּלֶךְ הָלוֹךְ וְזָעָקָה. 19 And Tamar put ashes on her head, and rent her garment of many colours that was on her; and she laid her hand on her head, and went her way, crying aloud as she went.
כ וַיֹּאמֶר אֵלֶיהָ אַבְשָׁלוֹם אָחִיהָ, הַאֲמִינוֹן אָחִיךְ הָיָה עִמָּךְ, וְעַתָּה אֲחוֹתִי הַחֲרִישִׁי אָחִיךְ הוּא, אַל-תָּשִׁיתִי אֶת-לִבֵּךְ לַדָּבָר הַזֶּה; וַתֵּשֶׁב תָּמָר וְשֹׁמֵמָה, בֵּית אַבְשָׁלוֹם אָחִיהָ. 20 And Absalom her brother said unto her: 'Hath Amnon thy brother been with thee? but now hold thy peace, my sister: he is thy brother; take not this thing to heart.' So Tamar remained desolate in her brother Absalom's house.

Thus, Tamar is clothed in a ketonet passim, just like Yosef. And she remains desolate in her brother's house, just as Yehuda's Tamar was to remain an almana in her father's house.

And this is followed by the slaying of brothers (including Amnon) as revenge when they go down to the sheep-shearing -- and David hears and mourns. Yehuda's meeting of Tamar was when he went down to the sheep-shearing, and this is juxtaposed with the attempt to kill Yosef, the pretending they killed Yosef, Yaakov's hearing that Yosef was dead and then mourning.

The purpose of such thematic echoes is not clear to me at this time, but I just thought I would make note of the parallels.

Thursday, July 03, 2008

Chukas: Shadal on Moshe's Sin

The meforshim have a lot to say on the identity of Moshe's sin in the incident with the rock, and a lot to say criticizing each others' position on it.

Eventually we aim to discuss all of the positions. Perhaps the best source for this would be Abarbanel, who goes through the various positions. But because this blog is often Shadal focused, and because he discusses a certain novel explanation at length (before rejecting it in favor of a traditional explanation), I'm going to cover him in this post. He starts with a nice humorous bit:

"Moshe Rabbenu only sinned one sin, but the commentators burdened upon him 13 sins and more, for each one invented of his own heart a new sin."

Heh.

The pasuk in Bemidbar 20:12 states:
יב וַיֹּאמֶר ה, אֶל-מֹשֶׁה וְאֶל-אַהֲרֹן, יַעַן לֹא-הֶאֱמַנְתֶּם בִּי, לְהַקְדִּישֵׁנִי לְעֵינֵי בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל--לָכֵן, לֹא תָבִיאוּ אֶת-הַקָּהָל הַזֶּה, אֶל-הָאָרֶץ, אֲשֶׁר-נָתַתִּי לָהֶם. 12 And the LORD said unto Moses and Aaron: 'Because ye believed not in Me, to sanctify Me in the eyes of the children of Israel, therefore ye shall not bring this assembly into the land which I have given them.'
and this -- יַעַן לֹא-הֶאֱמַנְתֶּם בִּי, לְהַקְדִּישֵׁנִי לְעֵינֵי בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל -- might give us a clue as to the nature of what Moshe and Aharon did wrong. Shadal writes:

יב]יען כי לא האמנתם בי : משה רבנו חטא חטא אחד, והמפרשים העמיסו עליו שלושה עשר חטאים ויותר, כי כל אחד מהם בדה מלבו עון חדש,
כי הנה דון יצחק אברבנאל הביא עשר דעות והוסיף עוד אחת מדעתו, והרשב"ן במגן אבות דף ע"ה הוסיף דעת אחרת, ורמבמ"ן הוסיף עוד אחרת, ואולי עוד כמה דעות אחרות נכתבו, ואני לא ידעתין; אשר על כן כל ימי נמנעתי מהעמיק החקירה בדבר הזה, מיראה שמא מתוך חקירותי יצא לי פירוש חדש, ונמצאתי גם אני מוסיף עון חדש על משה רבנו.

"Moshe Rabbenu only sinned one sin, but the commentators burdened upon him 13 sins and more, for each one invented of his own heart a new sin.

For behold, Don Yitzchak Abarbanel brings 10 opinions and adds one from his own opinion, and the Rashbatz {rather than Rashban} in Magen Avot, page 75 adds another opinion, and Mendelsohnn {Rabbi Moshe ben Mendel} adds another one. And perhaps there are several other opinions written, and I am not aware of them.

And because of this, all my days I refrained from delving into an investigation in this matter, from the fear lest from my investigation would come out to me a new explanation, and it would turn out that I, too, add a new sin to Moshe Rabbenu."

והנה לשעבר נחה שקטה דעתי בדעת רמבמ"ן שהיה החטא במה שפחדו מהקהל וברחו מפניהם אל אוהל מועד, ובפרט כי מצאתי כמחשבתו כן חשבו שלושה חכמים אחרים,
האחד ר' אברהם ביבאגו בספרו דרך אמונה (מאמר ב' סוף שער ו') שכתב וז"ל: עם שאני נפלא למה לא אמרו החושבים שמשה רבנו חטא (אמר שד"ל: דעת החכם הזה הוא כי משה רבנו ע"ה לא חטא, והיא הדעת העשירית שהביא דון יצחק, גם בעל העקדה הביא דבריו וסתר אותם, ועכשו המחבר מדבר לדעת האומרים שמשה חטא, והוא תמה למה לא אמרו) היות חטאו על שלא קידשו את הש"י, (כמו שכתוב ויבא) משה ואהרן מפני הקהל אל פתח אוהל מועד, שיורה קבלתם מהקהל פחד ורעדה, אשר לא היה ראוי אליהם, אבל יבטחו בש"י, ואימינו בו כי לא יעזוב את חסידיו, וכי הקהל לא יכול להזיקם, כי זה דרך מקדש את השם, ומה שלא קידשו את השם, נמנה זה להם למרי ומעל, והתחייבו מיתה עכ"ל.

And behold, in the past, my mind had rested on the position of Mendelsohnn, that the sin was that they feared the congregation and fled from before them to the Tent of Meeting. And specifically, when I found that along with Mendelsohnn are the thoughts of three other great sages.

The first one is R' Avraham Bibago in his sefer Derech Emuna (maamar 2, at the end of gate 6) where he wrote:
However, I am astonished why those who think that Moshe sinned do not say
(Here Shadal interjects: the position of this sage is that Moshe Rabbenu, peace upon him, did not sin, and this is the tenth position which Don Yitzchak Abarbanel brings; and also the author of the Akeida brings his words and refutes them. And now, this author {=R' Avraham Bibago} speaks according to the opinion of those who say that Moshe sinned, and he is astounded why they do not say...)
that his sin was that he did not sanctify the Divine name, as it is written {earlier in the perek}
ו וַיָּבֹא מֹשֶׁה וְאַהֲרֹן מִפְּנֵי הַקָּהָל, אֶל-פֶּתַח אֹהֶל מוֹעֵד, וַיִּפְּלוּ, עַל-פְּנֵיהֶם; וַיֵּרָא כְבוֹד-ה, אֲלֵיהֶם. 6 And Moses and Aaron went from the presence of the assembly unto the door of the tent of meeting, and fell upon their faces; and the glory of the LORD appeared unto them. {P}
which informs that they were fearful and shaking from the congregation, which was not fit for them to do, but rather they should have trusted in Hashem, and had faith in Him that He would not abandon his pious ones, and that the congregation would not be able to harm them, for this is the way that one sanctifies the Divine Name. And since they did not sanctify the name, this was reckoned to them as rebellion and improper action {?}, and they were liable to death.
והשני הוא בעל מנחה בלולה, וז"ל: ואני אומר אחרי בקשת המחילה מכל המפרשים , שחטא משה מפורסם בפסוק ויבא משה ואהרן מפני הקהל אל פתח אוהל מועד, כי תמורת שהיה להם להוכיח את ישראל ולעמוד בפרץ באמור להם מדוע תריבו את ה', הידו תקצר, וכאלה רבות, נסתרו אל פתח אוהל מועד כמו בורחים; ובאלה יתיישבו כל הפסוקים, כי אילו עמדו בפרץ היה שם שמים מתקדש; ולפי דעת כל המפרשים יהיה קשה, מה היה חטא אהרן, ועל פי דרכנו יהיה מתורץ הכל עכ"ל.

And the second is the author of Mincha Belula, and these are his words:
"And I say, after requesting forgiveness from all the commentators, that Moshe's sin is made well-known in the verse
ו וַיָּבֹא מֹשֶׁה וְאַהֲרֹן מִפְּנֵי הַקָּהָל, אֶל-פֶּתַח אֹהֶל מוֹעֵד, וַיִּפְּלוּ, עַל-פְּנֵיהֶם; וַיֵּרָא כְבוֹד-ה, אֲלֵיהֶם. 6 And Moses and Aaron went from the presence of the assembly unto the door of the tent of meeting, and fell upon their faces; and the glory of the LORD appeared unto them. {P}
For in place of what they they should have done in rebuking Israel and standing in the breach in saying to them, "why do you contend with God," "is his hand insufficient," and many like this, instead they concealed themselves away to the entrance of the Tent of Meeting like they were fleers. And with this, all the verses are settled. For if they had stood in the breach, the Name of Heaven would have been sanctified. And {meanwhile} according to the position of all the {other} commentators it is difficult, what was the sin of Aharon. But based on our approach all is answered."
והשלישי הוא קדמון מהנזכרים, הוא בעל ס' אַות נפשׁ (לא אות נפש, כקריאת וואלפיוס ודע ראססי), והוא פירוש על הראב"ע על התורה, ויש מיחסים אותו לרלב"ג, והוא שיבוש , והוא נמצא בכתב יד ביד ידידי החכם כמ"ר יוסף אלמנצי הי"ו, ולא נזכר בו שם המחבר, וההקדמה מתחלת במילות: אות נפש שואף רוח ורודף קדים. –והנה המחבר הזה כשהגיע לפרשת חקת יצא ממחיצתו שאינה אלא לבאר דברי הראב"ע, והרחיב פה והאריך לשון עד שלושה דפים לפרש חטא משה ואהרן, ולהיות הס' יקר המציאות מאד, ראיתי להודיע טיבו לרבים,

And the third is the earliest of those mentioned, he is the author of Sefer Avat Nefesh (not Ot Nefesh, as is the reading of Wolfius and De Rossi {thanks, S.} ), and it is a supercommentary on Ibn Ezra's commentary on the Torah. And some attribute it to Ralbag, and this is an error. And it is found in manuscript form in the hand of my friend, the sage Rabbi Yosef Almantzi, and the name of the author is not mentioned therein. And the preface begins with the words אות נפש שואף רוח ורודף קדים. And behold, this author, when he reached parshat Chukas, he left his usual bounds, which was just to explain the words of Ibn Ezra, and he widened his mouth and extended his language for three pages to explain the sin of Moshe and Aharon. And since the sefer is very dear to found, I saw fit to make known its contents to the public.

וזה לשונו: ואחר אשר פירשתי דעת אבן עזרא בשגגת חטא משה ואהרן ע"ה, נבאר דעתנו בו כי כל מה שפירשו המפרשים אינו מספיק, כבודם מונח במקומו, לפי הנראה לנו. ותחילה נבאר הספקות והסתירות הנראות בפירוש כל אחד מהם, כי בעברי על זה הסיפור נתתי לבי לדרוש ולתור, מה פשעם ומה חטאתם ועל מה נענשו הגדולים האלה, ועיינתי במה שפירשו בו המפרשים ולא ראיתי בו פירוש מספיק לפי הענין ולפי לשון הפרשה. כי לפי הר"ם אשר פירש כי החט (אמר שד"ל: כן הוא בכתב יד, ולא רציתי להגיה, כי כן מצאתי בהרבה ספרים כ"י, והיה זה כדי להבדיל חטא, שם העצם מן חטא, פועל) היה בעבור הראותו מידת הכעס באמרו שמעו נא המורים, אשר לא היתה אז ראויה במקום ההוא, יקשה למה נענש אהרן, כי משה לבדו אמר; גם יקשה עליו אמרו יען לא האמנתם בי, (וכי) זה מיעוט אמונה וחסרון קדושה, אם כעס עליהם בהיקהלם לריב על המים, אחר אשר ראו עיניהם המסות הגדולות והאותות והמופתים אשר עשה להם ה' זה ארבעים שנה במדבר? כי אם ביקשו מים בנחת ויישוב ואמרו למשה התפלל בעד עבדיך על המים, בלא קצף ובלא מריבה, היתה השאלה נכונה וראויה, אחר הצטרכם אליהם, כי זה מהדברים ההכרחיים לבני האדם וכל שכן למחנה גדול כזה? אך אמנם משה ע"ה לא כעס עליהם על השאלה, אך כעס עליהם על איכות ענינה, ר"ל בהיקהלם דרך מרי ושקשרו לריב עמו כדרך המורדים במלכם. ולכן אומר אני כי בדין כעס עליהם להוכיחם ולהשיבם מדרכם הרעה
And this is his language:
And now that I have explained the opinion of Ibn Ezra in the error of the sin of Moshe and Aharon, peace be upon them, we will explain our thoughts in it, for all that the commentators have explained in it is unsufficient, though their honor stays in its place, according to what appears to us.

And first we will explain the doubts and the contradictions which appear in the commentary of every one of them. For when I traversed this story, I set my heart to investigate and to scout out, what was their sin and what was their transgression, and upon what were these greats punished. And in delved into what the commentators explained, and I did not see in it a sufficient explanation, according to the substance and according to the language of the parsha.

For according to the Rambam, who explained that the sin {chet spelled chet tet, without the aleph}
(Shadal interjects: So it is in the manuscript, and I did not wish to correct it, for so I have found in many manuscripts of sefarim, and this was in order to separate chet, the noun, from chata, the verb.)
was that he exhibited the trait of anger in saying "listen now, you rebellious ones," which was not appropriate in this place. But then it is difficult why Aharon was punished, for only Moshe said it. It is also difficult according to his position why Hashem says 'Because ye believed not in Me.' (And is it so that) this is a reduction in faith and a lack in sanctification, if he grew angry with them when they gathered together to contend about the water, after their eyes had seen the great endeavors {?} and the signs and miracles that Hashem had performed for them 40 years in the wilderness? For if they requested water calmly and said to Moshe, "pray on behalf of your servants for the water," without striving and without contending, the request would have been proper and fitting, since after all it was needed by them, for this is one of the things people require, and all the more so for such a great encampment such as this.

However, Moshe, peace be upon him, did not grow angry at them about the request, but rather became angry with them on the way they posed it -- that is to say, by gathering together by way of rebellion, and that that bound {/conspired} together to contend with him in that way of those who rebel against their king.

And therefore, I say than it was lawful that he grew angry with them, to rebuke them and to bring them back from their evil way.
ר(ועוד הוא מאריך בקושיות על הרמב"ם ושאר המפרשים , ואח"כ הוא מבאר דעתו ואומר : ) ונאמר כי הנביא הוא בעל הבריאה השלמה אשר הכוונה אליו במציאות השפל, והוא מִכת המחוייב, יעשה פעולות הראויות, וישיב המענים הדוחים, לפי המקומות והענינים, ויגער ויכהה, ויבטיח ויקדים בגמולים טובים או בהפכם, או בהשגת המבוקש או בבלתי השגתו, הכל לפי הראוי, לפי הכתות והדעות, או לפי המבוקש שיימשך ממנו קדושת ה', בהראות פעולה נראית בגזרתו, ולא יתרשל וימתין להשיב לפי הענין ההוא, ויבטח בה' לקיים מאמרו, אחר שהוא מן הראוי למען ספר שמו, כי כן מצאנו במשה ע"ה שאמר לפרעה התפאר עלי וגו' (שמות ח' ה' ), בלי הקדמת נבואת ה' אליו בזה, אבל בטח שלא יביישהו, כמו שאמר אבן עזרא, אחר שהתשובה ראויה לפי המבוקש להתפרסם יכולת ה' בעולם השפל, שהיו כופרים בו פרעה ועבדיו. וכן עשה ג"כ בהיקבץ קרח וכל עדתו לחלוק על הכהונה, ענה תיכף בקר ויודע ה' את אשר לו ( למעלה ט"ז ה' ), וכל הנמשך אחריו, ולא נתרשל להשיב עד בוא דבר ה', אחר שהענין והמקום היו גורם וגוזר התשובה,וגזר והגביל זמן מדעתו שיוכיח בו ה' למי תיאות הכהונה ומי בחר עליה, בוטח כי יהיה כגזרתו. ועל כן התלוננו כל עדת ישראל ממחרת על משה ואהרן, ואמרו אתם המתם את עם ה' ( למעלה י"ז ו' ), ר"ל אתם מדעתכם הגבלתם זמן ההוכחה על ששבט לוי נבחר ואהרן כהן גדול, ובעבור קריבותכם אל ה', ובעבור שלא נספק בתורה הנתונה על ידיכם שמע ה' לקולכם והמית החולקים עליכם, אבל אין זה מופת חותך שנבחר שבט לוי, ולא אהרן. וזהו שאמר ה' יתעלה ( שם שם י"ז ) דבר אל בני ישראל וקח מהם מטה מטה לבית אב, והשכותי מעלי את תלונות בני ישראל וכו', כי כאשר פרח מטה אהרן לבית לוי, היה מופת שהשבט נבחר, ואהרן נבחר לכהן גדול, שהוא היה הראוי שבכל השבט; כי נראה כי עתה לא הריבו עמו רק על חילוף הבכורות שהיו מקריבים קודם שנבחר שבט לוי, ואל זה רמז באמרו כי כל העדה כולם קדושים , ר"ל עדת הבכורות, כמו שפירש אבן עזרא.
{Shadal interjects}: (And he extends further with questions on the Rambam, and the other commentators, and afterwards he explains his own position, and says:
And it is stated that the prophet is a master of the "ideal world," the ideal for which the "lowly world" was intended. And he, by compulsive force, should effect the actions which are fitting of and respond to the pressing {?} claims in accordance with the places and matters, and will be rebuke and reprimand, and make assurances and bring forth good acts or their opposite, either with the capability of the one requested or without his capability , all according to what is fitting, in accordance with the groups and the positions, or according to that which is requested, that extends from him the holiness of Hashem, when he displays an action it is apparent it is with his decree. And he should not be negligent and wait to answer according to that matter, but rather should trust that Hashem will fulfill his {=the prophet's} statement, since it is fitting in order to relate His Name.

For so we find by Moshe, peace be upon him, who said to Pharaoh {Shemot 8:5}:
ד וַיִּקְרָא פַרְעֹה לְמֹשֶׁה וּלְאַהֲרֹן, וַיֹּאמֶר הַעְתִּירוּ אֶל-יְהוָה, וְיָסֵר הַצְפַרְדְּעִים, מִמֶּנִּי וּמֵעַמִּי; וַאֲשַׁלְּחָה, אֶת-הָעָם, וְיִזְבְּחוּ, לַיהוָה. 4 Then Pharaoh called for Moses and Aaron, and said: 'Entreat the LORD, that He take away the frogs from me, and from my people; and I will let the people go, that they may sacrifice unto the LORD.'
ה וַיֹּאמֶר מֹשֶׁה לְפַרְעֹה, הִתְפָּאֵר עָלַי, לְמָתַי אַעְתִּיר לְךָ וְלַעֲבָדֶיךָ וּלְעַמְּךָ, לְהַכְרִית הַצְפַרְדְּעִים מִמְּךָ וּמִבָּתֶּיךָ: רַק בַּיְאֹר, תִּשָּׁאַרְנָה. 5 And Moses said unto Pharaoh: 'Have thou this glory over me; against what time shall I entreat for thee, and for thy servants, and for thy people, that the frogs be destroyed from thee and thy houses, and remain in the river only?'
without a preceding prophecy from Hashem in this. Rather, he trusted that He would not shame him, just as Ibn Ezra said, since the response was fitting according to that which was requested, in order to promulgate Hashem's ability in the lower world, about which Pharaoh and his servants denied.

And so did he do as well when Korach and all his congregation gathered to contend about the priesthood, he answered immediately {Bemidbar 16:5}
ה וַיְדַבֵּר אֶל-קֹרַח וְאֶל-כָּל-עֲדָתוֹ, לֵאמֹר, בֹּקֶר וְיֹדַע ה אֶת-אֲשֶׁר-לוֹ וְאֶת-הַקָּדוֹשׁ, וְהִקְרִיב אֵלָיו; וְאֵת אֲשֶׁר יִבְחַר-בּוֹ, יַקְרִיב אֵלָיו. 5 And he spoke unto Korah and unto all his company, saying: 'In the morning the LORD will show who are His, and who is holy, and will cause him to come near unto Him; even him whom He may choose will He cause to come near unto Him.
and everything after it, and he was not negligent to only answer after the word of Hashem came to him, since the matter and the place caused and decreed the answer, and he decreed and bounded a timeframe from his own mind in which Hashem would prove who should have the priesthood and who He chose for it, trusting that it would be in accordance with his decree.

And therefore, the entire congregation complained the next day about Moshe and Aharon and said {Bemidbar 17:6}:
ו וַיִּלֹּנוּ כָּל-עֲדַת בְּנֵי-יִשְׂרָאֵל, מִמָּחֳרָת, עַל-מֹשֶׁה וְעַל-אַהֲרֹן, לֵאמֹר: אַתֶּם הֲמִתֶּם, אֶת-עַם ה. 6 But on the morrow all the congregation of the children of Israel murmured against Moses and against Aaron, saying: 'Ye have killed the people of the LORD.'
The intent is to say that "you, from your own minds, set a time for the proof that the tribe of Levi was chosen and that Aharon was the High Priest, and because of your closeness to Hashem, and because you did not doubt in the Torah which was given via your hands, Hashem listened to your words and killed those who contended with you. But this is not is clear cut sign that the tribe of Levi was chosen, nor Aharon.

And this is what Hashem, yitaleh, stated {Bemidbar 17:17}
יז דַּבֵּר אֶל-בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל, וְקַח מֵאִתָּם מַטֶּה מַטֶּה לְבֵית אָב מֵאֵת כָּל-נְשִׂיאֵהֶם לְבֵית אֲבֹתָם--שְׁנֵים עָשָׂר, מַטּוֹת: אִישׁ אֶת-שְׁמוֹ, תִּכְתֹּב עַל-מַטֵּהוּ. 17 'Speak unto the children of Israel, and take of them rods, one for each fathers' house, of all their princes according to their fathers' houses, twelve rods; thou shalt write every man's name upon his rod.
...


כ וְהָיָה, הָאִישׁ אֲשֶׁר אֶבְחַר-בּוֹ--מַטֵּהוּ יִפְרָח; וַהֲשִׁכֹּתִי מֵעָלַי, אֶת-תְּלֻנּוֹת בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל, אֲשֶׁר הֵם מַלִּינִם, עֲלֵיכֶם. 20 And it shall come to pass, that the man whom I shall choose, his rod shall bud; and I will make to cease from Me the murmurings of the children of Israel, which they murmur against you.'
For when the staff of Aharon, to the house of Levi, buds, this is a sign that the tribe is chosen, and Aharon is chosen as High Priest, for he is the most fitting in the entire tribe. For it is apparent that now that do not contend with him except about the switching of the firstborns, who would bring offerings before the tribe of Levi was chosen. And to this he {=Korach} hinted when he said {Bemidbar 16}:
ג וַיִּקָּהֲלוּ עַל-מֹשֶׁה וְעַל-אַהֲרֹן, וַיֹּאמְרוּ אֲלֵהֶם רַב-לָכֶם--כִּי כָל-הָעֵדָה כֻּלָּם קְדֹשִׁים, וּבְתוֹכָם ה; וּמַדּוּעַ תִּתְנַשְּׂאוּ, עַל-קְהַל יְהוָה. 3 and they assembled themselves together against Moses and against Aaron, and said unto them: 'Ye take too much upon you, seeing all the congregation are holy, every one of them, and the LORD is among them; wherefore then lift ye up yourselves above the assembly of the LORD?'
the intent is to say the congregation of firstborns, just as Ibn Ezra explains.
וכן מצאנו בשמואל הרמתי כשנקבצו ישראל לשאול להם מלך, אשר לא היתה השאלה ההיא ראויה, כאשר היה להם מנהיג נכבד ונביא ה', כי אם בניו לא הלכו בדרכיו, אשר מינה שופטים עליהם, (היה להם) לשאול שישפטם הוא עצמו כבראשונה, או שימנה אחרים יראי אלהים אנשי אמת, והדבר הקשה יביאון אליו, וזהו שחרה בעיני שמואל כאשר אמרו תנה לנו מלך, ואמר ה' יתעלה אליו שמע בקול העם כי לא אותך מאסו וכו' ( שמואל א' ח' ו-ז ) ר"ל אחר שמיניתי להם דבר טוב ונאמן, והם שאלו להם מלך, לא הדבר מאסו, רק הממנה מאסו; ושמואל הזהירם על זה פעמיים ושלוש, ר"ל שלא ישאלו להם מלך, כאשר תמצא בעת פירסום בחירת שאול במצפה, אמר להם ( שם י' י"ט ) ואתם היום מאסתם את ה' אלהיכם, וישראל חשבו להתנצל מזה אחרי שמצאו בתורה שום תשים עליך מלך, בלי הגבלת זמן, חשבו שיהיה הרשות נתונה להם להקימו כשירצו ויהיה להם לב אחד להקימו, מבלי הבטה לפרנס הדור אם הוא ראוי אם לא, ולכן החזיקו בטעותם, וזהו שאמר להם שמואל בחדשו המלוכה בגלגל ותאמרו לא כי אם מלך יהיה עלינו ( שם ח' י"ט ) ולהשיבם מטעותם ולהודיע להם שחטאו ושיתנו תודה לה' וערפם לא יקשו עוד, כי כפירת העון שתי עונות, אמר להם שמואל בלי מצוות ה' אליו, הלא קציר חטים היום אקרא אל ה' ויתן קולות ומטר ( שם י"ב י"ז) , כי אם נצטוה מה' לומר להם זה, לא היה צריך להתפלל על הקולות והמטר, ובטח בה' שישמע תפילתו, אחר שהיה ראוי להודיע ולפרסם להם רעתם וחטאתם אשר מאסו ה' ודברו, כי אולי חשדוהו שחרה לו בעבור הסרת הגדולה מבניו, וכאשר ראו ישראל הקולות והמטר בעת הקציר, אשר לא היה משפט הארץ ההיא, כאשר הקדים להם שמואל, שבו אל ה' והודו על חטאתם, באמרם ( שם שם י"ט ): התפלל בעד עבדיך וכו' כי יספנו על כל חטאתינו רעה וכו'.
And so do we find in Shmuel the Ramati, when Israel gathered to ask for themselves a king, where this request was not fitting, since they had for themselves an honorable director and prophet of Hashem. For if his sons, whom he had appointed as judges over them, did not go in his ways, (they should have) requested that he himself judge them as before, or that he appoint over them Godfearing people, men of truth, and the difficult matter they would bring to him.

And this is why Shmuel was wroth, when they said to him "give us a king," and Hashem yitaleh said to him, {Shmuel I 8:6-7}

ו וַיֵּרַע הַדָּבָר, בְּעֵינֵי שְׁמוּאֵל, כַּאֲשֶׁר אָמְרוּ, תְּנָה-לָּנוּ מֶלֶךְ לְשָׁפְטֵנוּ; וַיִּתְפַּלֵּל שְׁמוּאֵל, אֶל-ה. {פ} 6 But the thing displeased Samuel, when they said: 'Give us a king to judge us.' And Samuel prayed unto the LORD. {P}
ז וַיֹּאמֶר ה, אֶל-שְׁמוּאֵל, שְׁמַע בְּקוֹל הָעָם, לְכֹל אֲשֶׁר-יֹאמְרוּ אֵלֶיךָ: כִּי לֹא אֹתְךָ מָאָסוּ, כִּי-אֹתִי מָאֲסוּ מִמְּלֹךְ עֲלֵיהֶם. 7 And the LORD said unto Samuel: 'Hearken unto the voice of the people in all that they say unto thee; for they have not rejected thee, but they have rejected Me, that I should not be king over them.
The intent is to say that I appointed for them a good and trustworthy thing, and they requested for themselves a king -- they did not reject the matter, but rather the One who appointed.

And Shmuel adjured them on this two and three times. The intent is to say that they should not request for themselves a king, as you will find at the time of the choosing of Shaul in Mitzpah, he said to them {Shmuel I 10:19}:
יט וְאַתֶּם הַיּוֹם מְאַסְתֶּם אֶת-אֱלֹהֵיכֶם, אֲשֶׁר-הוּא מוֹשִׁיעַ לָכֶם מִכָּל-רָעוֹתֵיכֶם וְצָרֹתֵיכֶם, וַתֹּאמְרוּ לוֹ, כִּי-מֶלֶךְ תָּשִׂים עָלֵינוּ; וְעַתָּה, הִתְיַצְּבוּ לִפְנֵי ה, לְשִׁבְטֵיכֶם, וּלְאַלְפֵיכֶם. 19 But ye have this day rejected your God, who Himself saveth you out of all your calamities and your distresses; and ye have said unto Him: Nay, but set a king over us. Now therefore present yourselves before the LORD by your tribes, and by your thousands.'
and Israel thought that they would be pardoned from this, after they found in the Torah "Place upon yourselves a king," without a time boundary specified, and they thought that the authority {/permission} was granted to them to establish him whenever they wanted, and they were of one heart to establish him, without a statement to the leader of the generation if he {/it} was fitting or not. Therefore, they maintained their error. And this is what Shmuel said to them when he inaugurated the kingship in Gilgal {Shmuel I 8:19}
יט וַיְמָאֲנוּ הָעָם, לִשְׁמֹעַ בְּקוֹל שְׁמוּאֵל; וַיֹּאמְרוּ לֹּא, כִּי אִם-מֶלֶךְ יִהְיֶה עָלֵינוּ. 19 But the people refused to hearken unto the voice of Samuel; and they said: 'Nay; but there shall be a king over us;
And in order to bring them back from their error and to make known to them that they sinned, and that they should give thanks to Hashem and not stiffen their necks further -- for denial of the sin is two sins -- Shmuel said to them, without the command of Hashem to them {Shmuel I 12:17}:
יז הֲלוֹא קְצִיר-חִטִּים, הַיּוֹם--אֶקְרָא אֶל-ה, וְיִתֵּן קֹלוֹת וּמָטָר; וּדְעוּ וּרְאוּ, כִּי-רָעַתְכֶם רַבָּה אֲשֶׁר עֲשִׂיתֶם בְּעֵינֵי ה, לִשְׁאוֹל לָכֶם, מֶלֶךְ. {ס} 17 Is it not wheat harvest to-day? I will call unto the LORD, that He may send thunder and rain; and ye shall know and see that your wickedness is great, which ye have done in the sight of the LORD, in asking you a king.' {S}
For if it were commanded from Hashem to tell them this, he would not need to pray about the thunder and rain. And he trusted in Hashem that He would hearken to his prayer, since it was fitting to inform them and promulgate to them their wickedness and their sin, in that they rejected Hashem and His word. For perhaps they suspected him that he was wroth because of the removal of the greatness from his sons. And when Israel saw the thunder and the rain at the time of the harvest, which was not the natural order of that land, as Shmuel introduced it to them, they returned to Hashem and admitted their sin, when they said {Shmuel I 12:19}
יט וַיֹּאמְרוּ כָל-הָעָם אֶל-שְׁמוּאֵל, הִתְפַּלֵּל בְּעַד-עֲבָדֶיךָ אֶל-ה אֱלֹהֶיךָ--וְאַל-נָמוּת: כִּי-יָסַפְנוּ עַל-כָּל-חַטֹּאתֵינוּ רָעָה, לִשְׁאֹל לָנוּ מֶלֶךְ. 19 And all the people said unto Samuel: 'Pray for thy servants unto the LORD thy God, that we die not; for we have added unto all our sins this evil, to ask us a king.'

וכן אליה בהר הכרמל, בהתפקר הדור ההוא לעבודת הבעל וכיחשו בה', אמר להם ( מ"א י"ח כ"א, כ"ג, כ"ד ) עד מתי אתם פוסחים על שתי הסעיפים, ויתנו לנו שניים פרים, והיה האלהים אשר יענה באש הוא האלהים, ועשה כל הפעולות הנכבדות, ר"ל בנין המזבח, ושתים עשרה אבנים למספר שבטי בני יעקב, והתעלה סביב ללכת המים סביב למזבח, כדי שיתפרסם עוצם יכולת ה' ונפלאותיו לדור הרע ההוא המסופקים ביכלתו ומציאותו ברדת האש ותאכל העולה, והמים אשר בתעלה ליחכה, והכול עשה אליהו ע"ה בלי הקדמת צוואת ה' אליו, אחר שהיה מן הראוי לעשות כן לפי הזמן והענין.
And so too, Eliyahu on Har HaCarmel, when that generation was forfeited to the service of Baal, and denied Hashem, he said to them {Melachim I 18:21}:
כא וַיִּגַּשׁ אֵלִיָּהוּ אֶל-כָּל-הָעָם, וַיֹּאמֶר עַד-מָתַי אַתֶּם פֹּסְחִים עַל-שְׁתֵּי הַסְּעִפִּים--אִם-ה הָאֱלֹהִים לְכוּ אַחֲרָיו, וְאִם-הַבַּעַל לְכוּ אַחֲרָיו; וְלֹא-עָנוּ הָעָם אֹתוֹ, דָּבָר. 21 And Elijah came near unto all the people, and said: 'How long halt ye between two opinions? if the LORD be God, follow Him; but if Baal, follow him.' And the people answered him not a word.
...
כג וְיִתְּנוּ-לָנוּ שְׁנַיִם פָּרִים, וְיִבְחֲרוּ לָהֶם הַפָּר הָאֶחָד וִינַתְּחֻהוּ וְיָשִׂימוּ עַל-הָעֵצִים, וְאֵשׁ, לֹא יָשִׂימוּ; וַאֲנִי אֶעֱשֶׂה אֶת-הַפָּר הָאֶחָד, וְנָתַתִּי עַל-הָעֵצִים, וְאֵשׁ, לֹא אָשִׂים. 23 Let them therefore give us two bullocks; and let them choose one bullock for themselves, and cut it in pieces, and lay it on the wood, and put no fire under; and I will dress the other bullock, and lay it on the wood, and put no fire under.
כד וּקְרָאתֶם בְּשֵׁם אֱלֹהֵיכֶם, וַאֲנִי אֶקְרָא בְשֵׁם-ה, וְהָיָה הָאֱלֹהִים אֲשֶׁר-יַעֲנֶה בָאֵשׁ, הוּא הָאֱלֹהִים; וַיַּעַן כָּל-הָעָם וַיֹּאמְרוּ, טוֹב הַדָּבָר. 24 And call ye on the name of your god, and I will call on the name of the LORD; and the God that answereth by fire, let him be God.' And all the people answered and said: 'It is well spoken.'
And he did all the honored actions -- that is to say, the building of the altar, and the 12 stones to the number of the tribes of Israel, and dug a ditch so that the water would go about the altar, in order that the greatness of the ability of Hashem, and his wonders, be promulgated to this wicked generation who were uncertain about His ability and His existence, when the fire descended and consumed the burnt-offering, and the water in the ditch was licked up. And all this Eliyahu, peace be upon him, did without the introduction of the command of Hashem to him, since it was fitting to do so in accordance with the time and the context.
ואחר זאת הקדמה נאמר כי כאשר נקהלו ישראל על משה ואהרן וביקשו המים אע"פ שלא ביקשו אותם בדרך נכונה, אבל בריב ומצה, היתה התשובה הראויה להם להבטיחם על שאלתם ולומר להם אל תיראו כי לא ימית אתכם ואת מקניכם בצמא, הלא כילכל אתכם במן מ' שנה, והיכה צור ויזובו מים ולא חסרתם דבר, לכן בה' אל תמרודו. מכל מקום (היה) ראוי לגעור בהם ולכהות על המריבה, לא שירפו ידיהם ויבהלו להשיב , כי מתנאי הנביא מידת הגבורה, לא יחת ולא ישוב מפני כול. ושני הנביאים האלו אשר נשלמו במידות ובשכליות ורעו את העם מ' שנה במדבר, והם משה ואהרן, לא תמצא שהשיבו להם שום דבר בהיקהלם עליהם על דבר המים, אבל רפו ידיהם, ומן המערכה נסו והלכו אל אוהל מועד מפני הקהל, כאמרו (פסוק ו') ויבא משה ואהרן מפני הקהל אל פתח אוהל מועד, ואמר אבן עזרא כדמות בורחים.- עד כאן לשון בעל אות נפש, ועוד האריך
And after this introduction, it is said that when Israel gathered to Moshe and Aharon and requested the water, even though they did not request it in a proper manner, but rather with contention and quarrel, the fitting response to them is to assure them about their request and say to them, "Fear not, for He will not let you and your cattle die in thirst. Did He not sustain you with manna for 40 years, and hit the rock and water flowed, and you did not lack anything. Therefore, do not rebel against Hashem."

Even so, it was fitting to castigate them and rebuke them about their contention. And not that their hands should become weak and to be confounded about what to respond, for one of the conditions of prophecy is the trait of might, not to become fearful of anything so as not to respond.

And these two prophets who were complete in traits and intellect, and shepherded the nation 40 years in the wilderness -- and they are Moshe and Aharon -- they did not find a single response for themselves, when they {=the nation} gathered to them about the matter of the water, but rather they weakened their hands, and from the assembly they fled and went to the Tent of Meeting from before the congregation, as it says {Bemidbar 20:6}:
ו וַיָּבֹא מֹשֶׁה וְאַהֲרֹן מִפְּנֵי הַקָּהָל, אֶל-פֶּתַח אֹהֶל מוֹעֵד, וַיִּפְּלוּ, עַל-פְּנֵיהֶם; וַיֵּרָא כְבוֹד-ה, אֲלֵיהֶם. {פ} 6 And Moses and Aaron went from the presence of the assembly unto the door of the tent of meeting, and fell upon their faces; and the glory of the LORD appeared unto them. {P}
and Ibn Ezra said, "in the manner of those fleeing."
End quote of the author of Avat Nefesh, though he continues at length.

ואמנם אע"פ שהסכימו לפירוש זה ארבעה חכמים מזמנים שונים ומארצות רחוקות, בלי שיידע אחד מהם מחשבת חברו, ואע"פ שגם אני בפירוש הזה בחרתי במשך ט"ו שנים ושיבחתיו לתלמידי, מכל מקום הנני רואה עתה כי אין משמעות הכתובים מסכמת עם הפירוש הזה;

כי הנה ה' לא הוכיחם כלל על אשר פחדו ועל אשר לא דיברו, והנה העיקר חסר מן הספר, ובפרט מילות על אשר מריתם את פי ( למטה בפסוק כ"ד ) לא יתיישבו כלל לפי הדעת הזאת, אלא בדוחק גדול, ואמיתת משמעותן אינה אלא שהיה שם צווי שלא קיימוהו, לא שחסרה להם הגבורה הראויה להם. גם מילות ויבא משה ואהרן מפני הקהל, אין שום הכרח שהכוונה לומר שהלכו כדמות בורחים (כדברי ראב"ע), כי "וינוסו" אין כתוב כאן, ומילת מפניהם אין ענינה אלא שהתרחקו מהיות לפניהם, על דרך ויסע עמוד הענן מפניהם ( שמות י"ד י"ט ). והרב החכם בעל ס' באר שבע, בספרו על התורה הנקרא צדה לדרך, הביא דברי בעל מנחה בלולה (בלי להזכיר שמו על הקלקלה), וכתב עליהם: ואני אומר שכל המפרשים לא רצו לפרש כן, כי הוא פירוש משובש, שאינו כדי לדבר הימנו כלל, שהרי מקרא מלא כתוב על אשר מריתם את פי, שעבר על דברו, ולפי פירושו לא עברו על דברו, אלא שלא הוכיחו את ישראל. ועוד האריך. –גם בעל הרכסים לבקעה דחה פירוש רמבמ"ן.

{Now, Shadal resumes talking, to evaluate this.}
And yet, even though four sages from different times and distant lands agreed to this explanation, without each one knowing the thoughts of his fellow; and even though even I chose this explanation for a length of 15 years, and praised it to my students -- even so, behold I now see that the implication of the verses does not agree with this explanation.

For behold, Hashem does not rebuke them at all about the fact that they feared and that they did not speak {to the congregation}, and so behold, the main point is missing from the sefer. And particularly, the words {Bemidbar 20:24}:
כד יֵאָסֵף אַהֲרֹן, אֶל-עַמָּיו, כִּי לֹא יָבֹא אֶל-הָאָרֶץ, אֲשֶׁר נָתַתִּי לִבְנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל--עַל אֲשֶׁר-מְרִיתֶם אֶת-פִּי, לְמֵי מְרִיבָה. 24 'Aaron shall be gathered unto his people; for he shall not enter into the land which I have given unto the children of Israel, because ye rebelled against My word at the waters of Meribah.
is not settled at all according to this position, except with great force. And the truth of their implication is only that there was there a command which they did not fulfill, not that they lacked the mightiness which was fitting for them.

Also, the words וַיָּבֹא מֹשֶׁה וְאַהֲרֹן מִפְּנֵי הַקָּהָל -- there is not any necessity that the intent was to say that they went in the manner of fleeing people (as the words of Ibn Ezra), for vayanusu is not written here, and the connotation of the word מפניהם is only that they distanced themselves from being before them, in the same way as in Shemot 14:19:
יט וַיִּסַּע מַלְאַךְ הָאֱלֹהִים, הַהֹלֵךְ לִפְנֵי מַחֲנֵה יִשְׂרָאֵל, וַיֵּלֶךְ, מֵאַחֲרֵיהֶם; וַיִּסַּע עַמּוּד הֶעָנָן, מִפְּנֵיהֶם, וַיַּעֲמֹד, מֵאַחֲרֵיהֶם. 19 And the angel of God, who went before the camp of Israel, removed and went behind them; and the pillar of cloud removed from before them, and stood behind them;
And the rav, the sage, the author of the sefer Be`er Sheva, in his sefer on the Torah called Tzeda laDerech, brings the words of the author of Mincha Belula (without mentioning his name on this mixup) and wrote upon them:
"And I say that all the commentators did not wish to explain to, for it is a defective explanation, of which it is not fit to speak of at all. For behold a full verse is written {Bemidbar 20:14} עַל אֲשֶׁר-מְרִיתֶם אֶת-פִּי, that he violated His word. Meanwhile, according to his explanation, he did not violate his word, but rather he did not rebuke {?} Israel.
And he continues on at length. Also the author of Rechasim leVik`ah rejects the explanation of Mendelssohn.

והנני רואה עתה כי משמעות הכתובים אינו אלא כפירוש רש"י וכל הקדמונים, שהיה ציווי ה' ית' שידברו אל הסלע ממש, וכמו שכתב בעל העקדה שהיה להם לומר אל הסלע: כה אמר ה', הסלע, תנה מימיך וישתה העם הזה, וכיוצא בדברים האלה, כאשר ידבר איש על רעהו בעל דעת כמוהו. הלא כה עשה אח"כ יהושע, שאמר ( יהושע י' י"ב ) שמש בגבעון דום וירח בעמק אילון. הן אמת כי (כדברי הרמב"ן) אין הנס גדול בדיבור מבהכאה, כי הכול שווה אצל הסלע, אבל מכל מקום לעיני ההמון הדיבור אל הסלע היה מתמיה יותר, והיה שם שמים מתקדש יותר.
And behold, I now see that the implication of the verses is only like the explanation of Rashi and all the early ones, that there was a command of Hashem yitbarach that they literally speak to the rock, and as the Baal haAkeda wrote that they should have spoken to the rock, saying "So says Hashem, Oh rock, give your water so that the nation will drink," and other such words to that effect, just as a man speaks to his friend, who possesses intellect like him. Did not Yehoshua do the same thing after this, for he said {Yehoshua 10:12}

יב אָז יְדַבֵּר יְהוֹשֻׁעַ, לַה', בְּיוֹם תֵּת יְהוָה אֶת-הָאֱמֹרִי, לִפְנֵי בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל; וַיֹּאמֶר לְעֵינֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל, שֶׁמֶשׁ בְּגִבְעוֹן דּוֹם, וְיָרֵחַ, בְּעֵמֶק אַיָּלוֹן. 12 Then spoke Joshua to the LORD in the day when the LORD delivered up the Amorites before the children of Israel; and he said in the sight of Israel: 'Sun, stand thou still upon Gibeon; and thou, Moon, in the valley of Aijalon.'

Now, it is true (like the words of Ramban) that the miracle is not greater with speaking than with smiting, for all is equal from the perspective of the stone. But still, to the eyes of the populace, speaking to the stone is more wondrous, and the name of Heaven is sanctified more.

ומה שאמר הרמב"ן כי מאחר שציוה: קח את המטה, יש במשמע שיכה בו, איננו נכון, כי אחר שאמר לו ה': ודברתם אל הסלע,ולא: והכיתם, היה להם לדבר ולא להכות, אלא שבשעת הדיבור היה להם לנטות ידם במטה על הסלע, בריחוק מקום ובלי לנגוע בו. והנה חטאת משה ואהרן היתה מרי ( ככתוב להלן כ"ד ), כי לא עשו כאשר ציום ה'; ונקראת ג"כ מעילה ( דברים ל"ב נ"א ) שענינו חסרון נאמנות, כי לא נאמנו עמו, כשלא דיקדקו לשמור דברו לעשות ממש כאשר ציום; וכאן נקראה חסרון אמונה (לא האמנתם בי) לא שהם לא האמינו באלהים, ושחשבו שיוכל להוציא מים מן הסלע בהכאה ולא יוכל להוציאם בדיבור (כי זה דבר שאין הדעת סובלתו); ולא שחשבו שאפילו בהכאה לא יצאו, וכמו שיוכל המתעקש להבין ממאמרם: המן הסלע הזה נוציא לכם מים, כי אמנם אם לא האמינו שיצאו המים, למה הקהילו את הקהל אל פני הסלע? הלא אין ספק כי באמרם: המן הסלע הזה וגו' לא היתה הכוונה אלא לומר: הייתכן בדרך הטבע שמן הסלע הזה יצאו מים? לא! ועתה התיצבו וראו את אשר יעשה ה', כי הוא יוציא לכם מים מצור חלמיש, -ולא היה בזה חסרון אמונה כלל.

And that which Ramban said that after He commanded "take the staff," there is the implication that he should smite with it, this is not correct, for after Hashem told him "and speak to the stone," and not "and hit the rock," they should have spoken and not struck. Rather, at the time of the speaking, they were supposed to stretch their hands with the staff towards the stone, with a distance of place and without touching it. And behold, the sin of Moshe and Aharon was rebellion (as is written later on in Bemidbar 20:24), for they did not do as Hashem commanded them. And it is also called me'ila, trespass (in Devarim 32:51) whose implication is a lack in trustworthiness, for they were not trustworthy with him, when they were not precise to keep His word to act exactly as He commanded them. And here, it is called a lack of faith ("you have not trusted in Me"), not that they did not believe in God, and that they thought that He was able to bring forth water with smiting and He was not able to bring it out with speech (for this is something that the intellect is not able to bear), and not that they thought that even with the smiting it would not come out, as someone who twists himself is able to understand from their speech, "will water indeed come out for you from this rock?" For if they did not believe that water would come out, why did they gather the congregation in front of the rock? Is it not so that there is no doubt that when they said "will water indeed come out for you from this rock?"their intent was only to say "it is possible based on the natural order that from this rock, water will come out? No! And now, face this and see that which Hashem does, for He will bring water from a flinty rock." And thus there was no lack of faith at all.

אבל מאמר יען לא האמנתם בי להקדישני ענינו: יען לא קידשתם אותי (לדבר אל הסלע, שדבר מתמיה כזה היה גורם קידוש ה' גדול מאוד בעיני ההמון), כאילו לא האמנתם בי (שאוכל לעשות כדבר הזה, להוציא מים בדיבור). והרי זה דרך מליצה נהוג הרבה
-- metonymia והוא הנקרא
, (החלפת מילה אחת באחרת מתוך סמיכות המושגים או לשם קיצור
), ודוגמתו כל משנאי אהבו מות ( משלי ח' ל"ו ), אין הכוונה שהם ממש אוהבים רעת עצמם, כי זה בלתי אפשר, אבל שמעשיהם הם כאילו היו אוהבים רעת עצמם; וכן חושך שבטו שונא בנו ( שם י"ג כ"ד ), והלא אינו חושך שבטו אלא להיותו אוהב את בנו, אבל הנמשך ממעשיו הוא כאילו היה שונאו, כי הוא גורם לו שיהיה נער משולח ובעל מידות רעות; וכן וימאסו בארץ חמדה ( תהלים ק"ו כ"ד ), והם לא מאסו בה, כי גם המרגלים אמרו טובה הארץ מאד מאד, רק פחדו מגבורת היושבים בה, ואמרו ( למעלה י"ד ג ): ולמה ה' מביא אותנו אל הארץ הזאת לנפול בחרב.
Rather, the statement "because you did not believe in Me, to sanctify Me," its meaning is: Because you did not sanctify Me (to speak to the rock, for something astounding as this would cause a great santification of Hashem in the eyes of the populace), it is as if you did not trust Me (that I am able to do something like this, to bring out water via speech).

And behold, this is by way of melitza, poetic phrase, often. And it is called "metonymy," to switch one word for another because of proximity of meaning or for the sake of brevity. And one example is {Mishlei 8:36}:
לו וְחֹטְאִי, חֹמֵס נַפְשׁוֹ; כָּל-מְשַׂנְאַי, אָהֲבוּ מָוֶת. 36 But he that misseth me wrongeth his own soul; all they that hate me love death.'
The intent is not that they literally love the their own hurt, for this is not possible. Rather, that by their actions, they are as if loving their own harm. And so too {Mishlei 13:24}
כד חוֹשֵׂךְ שִׁבְטוֹ, שׂוֹנֵא בְנוֹ; וְאֹהֲבוֹ, שִׁחֲרוֹ מוּסָר. 24 He that spareth his rod hateth his son; but he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes.
and is it not the case that he only held back the rod because he loved his son, but the consequence of his actions is as if he hates him, for he caused him to be a cast off child and possessor of bad traits. And so too {Tehillim 106:24}

כד וַיִּמְאֲסוּ, בְּאֶרֶץ חֶמְדָּה; לֹא-הֶאֱמִינוּ, לִדְבָרוֹ. 24 Moreover, they scorned the desirable land, they believed not His word;
But they did not scorn it, for also the scouts said that the land is extremely good, except that they feared the might of those who dwelled in it, and said {Bemidbar 14:3}
ג וְלָמָה ה מֵבִיא אֹתָנוּ אֶל-הָאָרֶץ הַזֹּאת, לִנְפֹּל בַּחֶרֶב--נָשֵׁינוּ וְטַפֵּנוּ, יִהְיוּ לָבַז; הֲלוֹא טוֹב לָנוּ, שׁוּב מִצְרָיְמָה. 3 And wherefore doth the LORD bring us unto this land, to fall by the sword? Our wives and our little ones will be a prey; were it not better for us to return into Egypt?'

והיותר קרוב לעניננו הוא מה שאמר שמואל לשאול (שמואל א' ט"ו כ"ו ) כי מאסתה את דבר ה', והוא באמת לא מאס את דבר ה', אבל מרה את דברו מחמלתו על אגג ועל מיטב הצאן והבקר. אבל איך היה ומהיכן נמשך הדבר הגדול והנורא הזה שקדושי ישראל משה ואהרן חטאו ומרו את פי ה', נראין הדברים שהכעס הוא שגרם להם, ובפרט כי נצטווה לקחת בידו המטה, שהיה בו פרח וציץ ושקדים והונח לפני ה' למשמרת לאות לבני מרי, ובהיותו בידו נצטייר בלבו מרי העם הזה, שכמה פעמים התלוננו על ה', לפיכך במקום שהיה לו לדבר אל הסלע, דיבר אל העם ואמר להם שמעו נא המורים, וכמו שפירש הרשב"ם: שמעו נא המורים, כמו שהמטה הזה שיש בו שקדים מוכיח שהוא למשמרת לאות לבני מרי. והנה הכעס הוא שגרם לו למרות את פי ה', אך לא על הכעס נענש (כדעת הרמב"ם), אלא על שלא דיבר אל הסלע. וכן אמר ר' אלעזר בן עזריה בספרי פרשת מטות (פיסקא ק') (והביאו רש"י למטה מ"א כ"א ), בשלשה מקומות בא (משה) לכלל כעס ובא לכלל טעות
And this which is much closer to our eyes is that what Shmuel said to Shaul {Shmuel I 15:26}:

כו וַיֹּאמֶר שְׁמוּאֵל אֶל-שָׁאוּל, לֹא אָשׁוּב עִמָּךְ: כִּי מָאַסְתָּה, אֶת-דְּבַר ה, וַיִּמְאָסְךָ ה, מִהְיוֹת מֶלֶךְ עַל-יִשְׂרָאֵל. {ס} 26 And Samuel said unto Saul: 'I will not return with thee; for thou hast rejected the word of the LORD, and the LORD hath rejected thee from being king over Israel.' {S}
and he in truth did not reject the word of Hashem, but rather diverted {?, rebelled against} His word when he had mercy on Agag and on the best of the sheep and cattle. But how was it, and how does it extend, this great and mighty thing, that the holy ones of Israel, namely Moshe and Aharon, sinned and rebelled against the word of Hashem -- it seemed apparent that anger was what caused this for them, and specifically because he was commanded to take the staff in his hand, the staff which had flowered, budded and developed almonds, and was resting before as a keeping of the sign for rebels. And when it was in his hand, there was described in his heart the rebellion of this nation, who had multiple times complained about Hashem. Therefore, in place of what he should have done, to speak to the rock, he spoke to the nation and told them "listen now, you rebels." And as Rashbam explained:"Listen now, you rebels! Just as this staff, which has almonds, proves, for it is for keeping of a sign to rebels. And behold, the anger was what caused him to rebel against the word of Hashem. However, he was not punished for the anger (in accordance with the opinion of Rashbam) but rather because he did not speak to the rock.

And so did Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah in Sifrei, parashat Matot (piska 100) (and Rashi brings it below on Bemidbar 31:21): In three places Moshe came to anger and thus came to error.

End quote of Shadal. Perhaps I {=Josh} will post some of my own thoughts in a subsequent post.

LinkWithin

Blog Widget by LinkWithin