Tuesday, April 14, 2009

posts so far for parshat Shemini

  1. Shemini sources -- a source roundup. Same idea as last year, but revamped, with over 100 meforshim on the parasha and the haftara, grouped into, e.g. Rashi's supercommentator's, Ibn Ezra's, masoretes, and so on.

  • Shemini sources: links by aliyah and perek to an online mikraos gedolos, as well as many, many meforshim on the parsha and haftara.
  1. Why the Ketores? And what foreign fire?
    The standard morning ketores offering, according to Rashbam. But then Shadal reverses himself and says it was their own separate offering; and that it was not their own fire, but a fire from heaven.

  2. "This is that which the LORD has spoken" But where?
  • Rendering Halachic Decisions Before One's Teacher
    • Another take on Nadav and Avihu's sin, from the gemara. This is a truly sublime midrash, once its nuances are pointed out. The specifics of the law they are rendering (that one should bring from a hedyot fire even though the Divine fire is present) parallels their error, rendering a halacha even though Moshe Rabbenu was present. This homily, I think, is part of the main meaning of the midrash. Also, an analysis of some of the midrash's contributing factors.
  • In Defense of Nadav and Avihu (AKA Conspiracy Theory)
    • I suggest it was a work accident. They brought a "strange fire," but this might just be meant to distinguish it from the holy fire that consumed them. As we see in context, the fire of Hashem came down and consumed the sacrifices, the people saw and fell on their faces. I try to pull a midrash into this as well.
  • Nadav and Avihu - What Did They Do Wrong?
    • A parallel to Korach and his congregation. Perhaps their sin was acting in an instance where only Aharon was supposed to act. Also, explaining the dispute between Aharon and Moshe.
  • This joke just doesn't work in a leap year, at least in its particular form. Oh well.
  • The Remaining Sons Taking The Remaining Mincha
    • Noteret and Notarim are used to describe both of them. The remaining sons should take the remaining of the offering.
  • Gecko vs. Geico (nice animal pictures too!)
    • The Anaka, one of the non-kosher species
to be continued...


Soccer Dad said...

The Rav of my Shul once asked why was it that the Machtos of Adas Korach were made into service vessel but we see no similar treatment of the Machtos of Nadav and Avihu.

I answered (and the Rav liked the response) that Adas Korach was commanded by Hashem to bring their (fatal) Ketores.

joshwaxman said...


Steg (dos iz nit der šteg) said...

Have you seen this week's G-dcast?

joshwaxman said...

that was fun.



Blog Widget by LinkWithin